Episode list

In 2005, Tracey Leigh Tetso fails to show up at a Motley Crue concert and is never seen again. Her husband, Dennis Joseph Tetso, was convicted of her 2nd degree murder in 2010 and sentenced to 18 years in prison. Her body is still missing.

On October 5, 1996, a college student at Northwest College in Powell, Wyoming, Berry Alexis Bryant, age 18, leaves a dorm party and gets a ride from the wrong classmate, vanishing into the night. An investigation by law enforcement led the police to Berry's body about 16 miles outside of Powell. It appeared that she had been in an vicious struggle with her attacker. Further investigation revealed that at the dormitory party, there was another teenager, 19-year-old Levi Collen who was interested in Berry. Investigators work this lead to find their suspect. In November 1996, Levi was convicted of first-degree murder, sexual assault and kidnapping. As a result, he was handed down three consecutive life sentences.

In 2016, a prosecutor must make an attempt to untangle the facts from fiction when the perpetrator of a brutal shooting that year claims that there is no randomness to his murders.

In 2017, a young couple's hope for a happily-ever-after ends in bloodshed, leaving two grandmothers to make sense of unbearable horror and grief.

Lisa Reeves wasn't looking for love when she met Randy Gwathney -- what she got, instead, was bloodshed.

In 2021, when 33-year-old Erika Verdecia goes missing, her family launches their own search for her. What their homegrown investigation uncovers is a tragic trail of bloodshed, 36 years in the making.