Mayor Jeff, along with Peanut, Butter and Jelly, goes on a quest to find the toys he hid from his sister near Hoohaw Rock. On a snowy day, PB&J try to look for a sled after realizing they don't have one.
Peanut accidentally gets his father's bagpipes in the lake, and struggles to recover the instrument. When Ootsie and Bootsie would not let their neighbors come aboard their new boat, the neighbors decide to form a separate club.
Peanut and Jelly think there is a troublesome ape in their home, and they are determined to get rid of it. Opal has a cold, thus her children recommend her to rest in bed while they be in charge of the house.
The Snooties invite their neighbors to a party, but their invitation to Peanut, Butter, and Jelly gets lost, leading the three to feel unwanted. The Otter kids look for ways to keep cool in the sweltering weather.
When Flick's team loses a volleyball game, he opts to have the next match in water because Jelly is aquaphobic. When Earnest tries to make popcorn for his kids, but gets interrupted by a buyer, the kids take matters into their own hands.
PB&J want to buy a birthday gift for their mother, but they're penniless, so they go to obtain teeth upon learning Flick will be paid by selling his detached tooth to the tooth fairy. Peanut expects a package after waiting for two weeks.
The children of Lake Hoohaw compete in a soap box race. Peanut is cast to play the protagonist of a play, but he develops anxiety upon learning that everyone in town will be watching the show.
Butter's balloon drifts out of the house. Peanut, Flick, and Munchy set their sights on a raffle where the winner will take home a robot that would do numerous chores.
Flick gets bored in a community act of collecting rubbish in the forest, thus he heads to explore a cave, and even goads Peanut to join him. When the Otter family is going on a camping trip, their neighbors want to come along.
Ernest aims to enter a fishing competition, but he needs a new rod to replace his old one which breaks. The Otter kids and their aunt are excited to see a boat show until rain suddenly comes, resulting in the event's cancellation.
