While investigating the disappearance of a pair of pearl shoes, two mischievous teens uncover an extravagant case that only they can solve.

After the Marlow Museum lists a cash reward for the missing Pompey Pearly Pumps, two mischievous teens, Christopher McNeely and Sprout Praxton, embark on an incredible investigation. However, the case uncovers the foreboding truths of their small town and with every clue found the two become one sip closer to danger.