- Ryan Siegel
- Christopher McNeely
- Vanessa Nottingham
- Sprout Praxton
- Karine Dieuvil
- Carol Fanning
- Anna Kate Womack
- Jackie Montgomery
- Ar'Darius Stewart
- Al Wilkson
- Brooke Livingston
- Mickey Wilkson
- Aaron Kienstra
- Nelson Wilkson
- Colleen Rua
- Lori McNeely
- Haley Johnson
- Ruth Handler
- Gregory Mallios
- Morgan Montgomery
- Susan Schuld
- Judge Joyce
- Sarah Main
- Cordelia
- Zoe Wilde
- Jen Johnson
- Sophia Young
- Wilma
- Emily Chaviano
- DeeDee
- Trevor Spence
- Curator
- Dajalynn Sanchez
- Penelope
- Savannah Simerly
- Sprout's Mom
- Matt Guernier
- Nick Newman
- Julia Dansereau
- Waitress
- Nina Dramer
- Sammy Sanderson
- Anna Roman
- Local TV Personality
- Bakari Garvin
- Bailiff
- Elaina Walton
- Tilda
- Jacob I. Titus
- Franklin
- Lukas Chaviano
- Bob Bobwell
- Bryce Hagen
- Bus Driver
- Joseph Meisner
- Sprout's Dad / Bruce McNeely
- Niko Soroko
- Chief of Police
- Isadora Ferber
- Mail Woman
- Abby Aspell
- Juror / Librarian
- Molly Heyner
- Flapper Dancer Captain
- Cassie Ventura
- Flapper Dancer #1
- Ella Romaine
- Flapper Dancer #2
- Jamie Harris
- Flapper Dancer #3
- Lauren Cadle
- Flapper Dancer #4
- Lowell Brito
- Dancing Waiter
- Laura Chiarello
- Officer #1
- Skylar Geraghty
- Officer #2
- Tanya Pattison
- Officer #3
- Armand Ercoli
- Guard #3 / Bouncer #1
- Jason Bertino
- Bouncer #2
- Allie Beltran
- Townsperson #1
- Ashley Blum
- Townsperson #2
- Ace Cabalan
- Roaring 20s Guest #1
- Graham Corbett
- Roaring 20s Guest #8
- Sean Cunningham
- Roaring 20s Guest #12
- Thomas Driscoll
- Guard #8 / Gentleman in Black Void #3
- Natalia Dubon
- Townsperson #12 / Hair Salon Customer
- Claudia Galindo
- Townsperson #4
- Kara Gordon
- Bookstore Shopper
- Zack Gropper
- Guard #10
- Stephanie Gutierrez-Diaz
- Townsperson #17
- Louise Harris
- Townsperson #7
- Keshawn Herbert
- Guard #6
- Hannah Hill
- Roaring 20s Guest #9
- Angie Hyse
- Roaring 20s Guest #2
- Aleksandr Kalishman
- Guard #1
- Andrea Lopez
- Guard #2
- Victoria Maskas
- Townsperson #18
- Emma McAvoy
- Roaring 20s Guest #7 / Guard #4
- Minh Nguyen
- Lawyer
- Charles Nottingham
- Roaring 20s Guest #4
- Elisabeth Nottingham
- Roaring 20s Guest #5
- Daniel Nuñez
- Townsperson #6
- Maria Parra
- Townsperson #10
- Todd Reeger
- Roaring 20s Guest #14
- Thomas Reid
- Roaring 20s Guest #13 / Guard #9
- Beatrice Reyes
- Townsperson #3
- Emily Rüts
- Roaring 20s Guest #6
- Mason Schmidt
- Gentleman in Black Void #1
- Tara Schulman
- Female Jogger
- Janvi Shah
- Roaring 20s Guest #10
- Nyq Smith
- Guard #7
- Igor Sokolov
- Waiter #1
- Natalie Spector
- Townsperson #13
- Gillian Stine
- Guard #5
- Storm Tracy
- New Gardener
- Trevor Wayne
- Waiter #2
- Connor Neun
- Townsperson #5
- Michael Golden
- Townsperson #11
- Noah Yager
- Townsperson #14
