Things go wrong for Jim when he talks to God about having women be more like men. When Cheryl and Dana become just like Jim and Andy, Jim asks God to make men be more like women, but they turn into overly sensitive women.
Cheryl thinks she is losing her looks and charm when other men no longer look at her with desire. Jim comes up with a scheme to help Cheryl get her confidence back.
Cheryl tells Jim to wear an ID badge when he goes running in the morning, but he does not want to. When he has an accident on his run, he is taken to the hospital without ID. Jim realizes he needs to take precautions for his family.
Jim and Cheryl start an argument about dessert on their romantic evening together, and in the morning, they just decide to let it go. Andy finds out and decides to stir up the argument between them.
Cheryl goes to Florida to care for her mother when she is sick, leaving Jim alone to take care of the children. When neighborhood mom's find out Jim is struggling at home, they all pitch in to help. Each one thinks they are the only helper.
Jim still struggles with household duties while Cheryl is out of town, but has real problems when Ruby asks to go shopping for a training bra. Jim asks Dana to be the temporary mom for shopping. Turns out, Ruby is getting ready for a date.
Jim is surprised to find out the Gracie has started her monthly periods, and Ruby is angry that she has not yet started. Ruby and Gracie argue about everything.
While Cheryl's still in Florida, Jim gets the courage to throw out all the old baby clothes she's saved over the years, only to find out he's not so courageous, after all.
Jim takes advantage of Cheryl's forgetfulness as a result of her pregnancy by turning the girls' new bedroom in the basement into a media room for he and Andy.
Andy remembers the dinner gift card Jim gave him for his last birthday the day before it's due to expire and asks Jim to accompany him. The only problem is Jim felt slighted in giving it to Andy so he's already cashed it in.
Andy may have hit the jackpot with the new lady in his life, but Jim may have screwed it up when he agrees to chaperone the lady's two daughters, and his own, to a teenaged girls' concert and loses them all.
Andy finds a girl who seems to really like him and wants to spend time with him. Andy realizes it is too good to be true and starts sabotaging the relationship.
Cheryl still wants to have game night even though she is confined to bed. The gang gathers around the bed, and Dana realizes Cheryl is cheating at the game.
Cheryl and Jim have twin boys. Jim cannot tell them apart. One night when taking care of the boys, Jim dreams the devil visits and says Jim has to give up one of the twins.
