Episode list

Allen shows his Christmas decorations, and a new TV in the Nintendo room. Ullen walks in, and Allen tells him that Bellen is standing next to him. He doesn't see Bellen, and realizes that Allen is the only clone who can see ghosts. After the theme song, Allen spends the next day talking to The Allen Group, and shows a chocolate calendar. Then, he shows Christmas presents from last year. Allen says Merry Christmas Eve with a lot of eves, and he shows Fluffy, who says the same thing, but without stopping. He puts Fluffy on the floor and teleports away from the camera.

Ollen lands on the floor in the backwards dimension after being hit by a blast of telekinesis. He sees a "blanket monster" standing on the table, which falls on the floor. He is revealed to be Bark Man, and he tells Ollen that he fired Bark Junior. He then leaves, and Ollen continues on his adventure to find Arllen. After the theme song, Ballen says, "Happy Ballentines Day" to Allen. While confused, Allen gets knocked over by another blast of telekinesis. He then mentions that February 17th is The Allen Show's second anniversary, and it's only three days away. After realizing that Ollen and Arllen might not be back by then, Allen notices that Ballen disappeared. Meanwhile, in the backwards dimension, Ollen waves his arms, and hears Allen's voice from the normal dimension. Suddenly, Ballen and Springy appear in the room. Later, Ollen decides to run around Allen's room, still in the other dimension. He sings a song while jumping on a bed, but falls off. Allen is in his room in the normal dimension, and walks around, remembering old episodes. He remembers Nibbles, at the end of season one, and the old bunk bed, which was split into separate beds. Then, Allen suddenly falls onto his bed, and has a flashback of himself telling Erllen not to become evil, but after Allen leaves, Erllen says that Allen can't tell him what to do, and roars. Ullen wakes Allen up and tells him that Ollen found Arllen in the backwards dimension. They both go there, and visit Allen's Grandma's house. Bark Man appears, and Allen tells him that he can join them for the anniversary party.

Allen wakes up to an alarm of Cami repeatedly saying, "Wake up!" He gets dressed and goes to the kitchen. While saying hi, Allen's hand randomly blasts telekinesis at Ellen. In the Nintendo room, Ullen tells Allen that he's working on a gadget that can help them spy on Bark Man.

After lunch, Allen decides to go sit on the couch. Arllen tells him that he's making episode three of Thomas the Thumb, and Allen goes to watch a DVD of Diary of a Wimpy Kid: The Long Haul. After a time-lapse of Allen eating spaghetti, he goes downstairs, where Ullen tells him that he's going to test his new gadget on Ballen.

Thirty minutes later, Allen gets a call from Ullen telling him to go downstairs. Ullen tells him that he tested the gadget on Ballen, and he died. Allen then hears his alarm, and wakes up. Everything happens the exact same way, and after hitting Ellen with a blast of telekinesis, Allen remembers everything.

Nobody else remembers, until Allen proves it to Ullen by telling him everything about the gadget. After lunch, Allen says that he hopes that the day stops looping, and Arllen walks away confused. This time, he watches Diary of a Wimpy Kid: Rodrick Rules. While eating spaghetti, Allen remembers that he needs to warn Ullen about the gadget.

Allen runs downstairs and makes the gadget fly out of Ullen's hands. He then explains that it was going to kill Ballen. One hour later, Allen and Ullen hear the alarm, and they both wake up remembering everything. Later, Ballen finds Ullen's gadget, and it explodes on him. The day loops again, and again, and again.

Allen pushes Ellen away, and runs downstairs to get Erllen to believe him. Allen wakes up again and gets Erllen to believe him, but he accidentally says, "I forgot you." Allen wakes up one more time, and Erllen doesn't remember.

Allen rushes downstairs to ask Erllen if he remembers what he was told in the previous time loop. After Erllen says no, Allen decides to give up. Ullen tells him that he can make a gadget that will stop the day from repeating. Later, Ullen says that it's almost finished, but he's going to take a break first. Allen then wakes up in the next loop, and they realize that they'll never have time to finish it, since the day keeps getting reset.

Two years later, on the same day, Ullen decides to leave. Allen looks at old photos and videos, knowing that he'll never have new memories. He wishes that he could go back to a different day, and notices his time machine. Bark Man appears, and reveals that he began the time loop. Allen runs upstairs to find Ullen, but he's already gone.

He finds a note from Ullen that says that he's left to go on his final adventure before the universe ends. This causes Allen to realize that this is the final loop. Erllen and Allen try to use their telekinesis on Bark Man, but they're powerless. Bark Man then takes away Allen's powers, causing him to die from everything that would have killed him while he was indestructible.

Erllen also gets his powers taken away, and falls to the floor. Meanwhile, Ullen is in Allen's dad's yard when he gets erased from existence from Allen being gone. Chad finds Bark Man in the Nintendo room, and he tells Chad that he's Allen wearing a disguise. He then overhears Bark Man saying that it's time to destroy the universe.

Upstairs, Chad tells the other stuffed animals what he heard Bark Man say. They begin to disappear, and by the time they get downstairs, Squeaky, Bark Junior, Whatever his name is, Scruffy, and Fluffy are the only ones left. Soon, Squeaky and Whatever his name is are gone too.

Scruffy and Fluffy get to Bark Man, but Scruffy quickly disappears. Finally, Fluffy is gone, but Bark Man hears a voice. Mr. Bag appears, revealing that he can bring people back to life. Allen wakes up, and he teams up with Erllen and Ullen to get Bark Man to take his mask off.

The person under Bark Man's mask is Erllen. Everyone is confused, since Erllen was still standing next to Allen. Evil Erllen (Bark Man) explains that when Allen stopped his past self from being evil, he caused Bark Man's time line to be erased from existence, only leaving him. This caused Evil Erllen to become evil, and created his villain name, Bark Man.

Allen, Ullen, and Erllen team up to send Bark Man to a random dimension. The next morning, Allen wakes up, realizing that it's finally the next day.