Episode list

Mishawaka, Indiana: Theresa Burns was murdered in 1988. It took 28 years to find justice.

Firefighters tried to save a family from a fire; victims died. Police investigated, suspecting arson due to another deadly fire nearby that killed an elderly couple.

A camper finds the body of Mennonite woman Sasha Krause, 27, in Arizona. Airman Mark Gooch is tied to her 2020 kidnapping and murder through evidence despite being strangers from different Mennonite communities. He receives life in prison.

Mengqi Ji Elledge, An exchange student, found a career and a love match in the idyllic Missouri university town of Columbia. So, it was a shock to her friends and family when she disappeared, leaving both her child and cell phone behind.

Murder in Tennessee, July 2010: Ten days after NBA player Lorenzen Wright went missing, the basketball player's body was found in a swamp, shot 11 times. Lorenzen called 911 but was only able to ask for help, and then the 911 dispatcher heard 11 gunshot sounds. The police carried out an investigation, but came up empty as to who the killer or killers were, and the case went cold. During this time, Lorenzen Wright's mother, Deborah Marion, steadfastly worked hard to keep her son's case active. The investigation 'heated up' when the Memphis police obtained help from the FBI several years after the murder. Using clues from an informant, the investigators were able to successfully arrest Lorenzen's wife, Sherra Wright (the mastermind of the crime, and the mother of their six children) and her gardener, Billy Ray Turner (the actual killer) for the murder. The suspects were found guilty and sentenced to jail.

When a hairstylist, Joleen Cummings, failed to pick up her children for a planned celebration, she was reported missing by her ex-husband. Investigators discovered a bloody scene at the salon, but the hairstylist and her SUV were gone.

Jill Halliburton Su, an heir to the Halliburton oil dynasty fortune, is discovered dead in the bathtub by her son Justin at her upscale home in a Florida gated community in 2014.

Florida, June 2017: Makeva Jenkins, age 33, a successful businesswoman and mother of three, posted on Facebook that she had grown her business to six figures. Just a few years beforehand, she had been homeless. Hours after her Facebook post, she was shot dead with a bullet to the head by a masked gunman. The horrible truth is that her death was a murder-for-hire. The mastermind of the crime was her husband, Euri Durrell Jenkins. The "middle man" of the crime was Dametri Dale. The gunman of the crime was Joevan Marquise Joseph. They were all arrested and charged with the murder. Euri's entire motive to kill his wife was a failed one. When he called to inquire about collecting the proceeds on the life insurance policy that was on his wife, he found out that he was not the beneficiary on the insurance. The case was "cracked" when the "middle man" Dametri Dale came forward voluntarily to confess to the homicide investigators. The killer, Joevan Joseph, took a plea deal for 15 years in prison. The middle man, Dametri Dale, took a plea deal for 15 years of probation with no jail time. The mastermind, Euri Jenkins, pleaded "not guilty" but was found guilty by the jury at trial. He was sentenced to life in prison with no possibility of parole.

"Geauga's Child" in Geauga County, Ohio was the only name a dead newborn baby boy had during the 26 years it took to solve this gruesome cold case. The baby was found near Sidley Road in Thompson Township, Ohio on March 25, 1993. The child was partially dismembered and still had his umbilical cord attached. Authorities said the child had been placed in a trash bag and left in a wooded area but was dragged to the side of the road by animals. The case was solved with forensic genetic genealogy using DNA. In June 2019, the newborn's mother, Gail Eastwood-Ritchey of Euclid, Ohio, was arrested and charged with his murder. At that time, she told detectives that this was the second newborn child she had abandoned. In the end, now age 51, Gail Eastwood-Ritchey was found guilty and sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole in 15 years.

Just after 8:00 AM on September 16, 2016, Todd Kendhammer calls 911 in a panic, describing a freak car accident on a rural road outside La Crosse, Wisconsin involving his wife, Barbara Kendhammer, age 46. Police are suspicious of Todd's responses in the interrogation room. Plus, forensic details from the autopsy report cast further doubt on his story. Prosecutors contend Todd Kendhammer fatally beat his wife of 25 years and tried to conceal her death by staging a car accident. Kendhammer says she died when an airborne pipe pierced his windshield and struck her in the head. In the end, Todd Kendhammer was arrested, convicted and sentenced to life in prison, with the possibility of parole in 30 years.

In 2015, Amanda Colley's house was ransacked, leading to gunfire that killed her and Lindy. Amanda's ex-husband, James Colley, was arrested for double murder, with Lamar Douberly and Rachel testifying against him at trial.

Greeley, Colorado, February 2020: Jazz trumpet player Stanley Scott Sessions, age 53, fails to show up for a gig. He was a popular trumpet player for the Colorado band "The Movers and Shakers". His body is found a few days later, wrapped in plastic, partially burned and hidden in a forest. Investigators trace his last known whereabouts to the residence of his new love interest, Heather Frank. Unfortunately, there was a love triangle. In the end, Kevin Dean Eastman, age 50, was sentenced to two consecutive life sentences as well as an additional 27 years after he was convicted of killing his ex-girlfriend, Heather Frank, and the man she was dating, Scott Sessions, within a week of each other in February 2020.

February 8, 2017, Scioto Grove Metro Park in Grove City, Ohio: Reagan Delaney Tokes, age 21, was a student at Ohio State University. She was abducted while leaving her job in downtown Columbus, Ohio. A caller reported the discovery of her body in a local park. Detectives worked hard to solve this case, and in the end, habitual offender Brian Golsby was arrested. Golsby had been on parole when the attack took place. He was convicted of her rape and murder in March 2018 and was sentenced to life in prison.