In October 2007, Fairview Park, Ohio, emergency crews were called by neighbors to 67-year-old Gwen Bewley's house. She was found dead in her burned-out kitchen.
A 67-year-old man was found murdered in his home in Bridgeport, West Virginia. Kelly and Yolanda discover that he may be his own best witness, having kept a detailed diary recording his daily life and interactions.
Early one morning in October 2009, Paul Bowman was found dead in bed from blunt force trauma to his head. Arlington, Texas police found the house in disarray, as in a robbery, but nothing valuable was missing.
Rupinder Goraya, her husband Kultar, and their two-year-old son Devyn came to Fort Myers, Florida, from India on a work permit. After developing a cancerous mass and taking a leave from work, she disappeared.
In 2011, Marie Carlson, a beautiful, young bipolar mother, of 2 has disappeared. A group text was received from her to say she had to get away. She has not been seen or heard from since. There seems to be only 2 suspects, the local Pastor and his wife for whom, Marie had been a surrogate for after giving birth a few months earlier.
Greenville, Ohio, Dennis Young and Kim Stephan were found shot dead inside Young's home. Stephan's ex-husband Bob and a woman named Patty Burton are the main suspects in the case.
Hernando County, Florida, in 1981, a daughter returns home from school to find her mother, Laverne Mackey, gone without explanation. The investigators conclude she was murdered and that her husband, Merl Mackey, is the only suspect.
John Walsh interviews the investigative team for their behind-the-scenes insights. Exclusive updates on past cases and questions to Kelly and Yolanda will be featured.
Paducah, Kentucky, Dr. Frank Shemwell, is brutally murdered and set on fire in his kitchen. Suspects include Dr. Shemwell's younger wife (Penny), her son, and her lover.
Stacy Dillon, is killed in his hometown of Cleveland, Tennessee. The investigative team is able to narrow the suspect list down to one - Stacy's boyfriend, Robert Houston III.
West Palm Beach, Florida, Gwen Greenblatt is cornered in her apartment and shot twice. It seems her abusive husband (Matt Greenblatt) is the murderer, but first, investigators must find who left a smoldering cigarette outside her apartment.
Eric and Dottie Ferguson were shot multiple times inside their rural Spartanburg, SC home. The team decides that a random intruder is incredibly unlikely, due to how remote the home was.
Fort Myers, Florida, A 22-year-old murder case of a woman found shot in the head, covered in bloody sheets and dumped behind a community recreation center.
Johnson County, IA to work with the sheriff's office on the 1995 case of a mother and gifted artist (Sue Kersten) who was found dead in her car after an explosion. Her husband's (Steve Klein) violent characteristics come to light.
Ben Cooper is found dead of an apparent suicide by his wife, Samantha Price. Because of the location of the gun shot to the back of Ben's head, the team focuses on building a case against Samantha.
White Settlement, Texas, Laura Walsh was sexually assaulted and stabbed to death in her home. Months later, two men, Gene Giddens and Jonathan "Keith" Durington, have their throats slashed. All 3 victims were set on fire after their deaths.
The White Settlement, Texas, investigation continues. After interviewing a large number of suspects, the team seems to be getting nowhere, until a recorded phone call of Doughlas Wright changes the outlook of the investigation.
