The effects of the boogeymen create shocking events on the server, causing death. Tango creates a game, providing people to bet their life for a chance of gaining more. Meanwhile, the attempts of one boogeyman rids them of their lives.
Lizzie has to choose a target to cure herself of the boogey-curse. Meanwhile, Grian and Mumbo try to get revenge on Scar's scam against them earlier, but Scar already has a plan for the situation.
Joel's thirst for kills pays off, as he manages to shoot Grian off a high place, turning him red. Cleo finds her closest ally betraying her for his own good. The recent events cause more red lives to appear around the server.
Joel and Grian continue to cause chaos as red lives, aiming to destroy the Scottage. Meanwhile, Scar manages to bargain multiple alliances with his large number of lives, but quickly begins losing them all.
When the server is greeted with a shocking amount of boogeymen, many alliances fall into massive chaos. Due to this, many members are put right into red life, and the Southlands fall apart.
When a large portion of the server turns to their last life, the red names create an alliance. Meanwhile, Grian and Impulse execute their plan of spawning a Wither, and Etho has to abandon Team B.E.S.T to join the other greens.
The status of the Red Team gets worse, when Tango is killed by his own trap. The non-reds group up to hunt down the last two red lives remaining, but Scott has to choose whether to betray his allies, or keep his third life.
