The Cryptkeeper and the Old Witch meet at the beach to swap stories: A man and a woman find that they have a lot in common while investigating rumors of a monster dwelling in a lake.
After besting the Vaultkeeper in shadow puppets, the Cryptkeeper tells two stories: A young boy wishes he can get revenge on his tormentors. Then, an archaeologist discovers a tomb and learns why others before have died trying to find it.
After months of researching the disappearance of a 1930's Mad Scientist, an adventurous Cub Reporter named Sally decides to follow up her leads and drive out to a sleepy town where she suspects the doctor might still be hiding out.
The Old Witch, The Cryptkeeper and The Vaultkeeper compete to decide who tells one story. The Witch wins, so she tells the tale of a boy who challenges a demon to a basketball game that could mean the end of his life if he loses.
After incapacitating Scariff Cryptkeeper in a ghost town, the Vaultkeeper tells the story about a young man who goes to visit his aunt which leads to a trip inside an abandoned mine filled with unusual shapes and a dark secret.
The Old Witch takes over telling another story after turning the Cryptkeeper into a scarecrow. Wendell from "Hyde and Go Shriek (1993)" falls for Rose, a new girl at school with a rather "weedy" family secret.
A boy named Eddie is followed home by a troll after crossing a bridge. Now it's up to him and his friend Sheldon, who knows almost everything about monsters, to defeat the troll when it kidnaps Eddie's older brother.
During a trip to the carnival, a boy's birthday is being spoiled by his skeptical uncle, but the latter of whom soon has his views of the supernatural challenged when they take a ride through a frighteningly realistic haunted house.
Two surfer dudes, none other than Mike and Ben from "Ghost Ship (1993)", accidentally get on a train headed for Transylvania, where they must fight back against vampires.
