Episode list

Stay-at-home mother Danielle Redlick is charged with the murder of her husband, pro sports executive Michael Redlick. After holding onto her original account about the murder of her husband for nearly three years, Danielle finally takes the witness stand and her story takes a turn.

Florida man charged with murdering ex-girlfriend, her parents, and boyfriend after their bodies were found on the roadside. Investigation leads to his conviction and life sentence.

A romance author writes about how to murder a husband, and then kills her spouse. It might sound like the plot of a novel, but it happened in Oregon in 2018. Nancy Crampton Brophy, 72, shot and killed her husband, Daniel Brophy, on June 2, 2018 at the now-closed Oregon Culinary Institute, where he was a well-respected instructor. She was arrested and charged with second-degree murder in September 2018, and was found guilty in May 2022 after a seven-week trial. She was sentenced to life in prison.

Jury Trial Begins - February 7, 2022, Pasco County, Florida: After a seven-year delay, the jury trial for retired Tampa Police Captain Curtis Reeves Jr., now age 79, begins. He stands accused of murdering Chad Oulson, age 43, on January 13, 2014. Reeves was outraged over popcorn having been thrown on him by Chad Oulson during a matinee movie performance at the Cobb Theater in Wesley Chapel, Florida. The theater has changed its name since 2014 and is now the Grove Theater. Before the shooting, during the previews on the big screen, Reeves had admonished Oulson to stop texting and to put away his phone. Reeves then reported Oulson to the theater management. Tempers of both men escalated from there forward. Reeves' criminal defense lawyer claims that Curtis acted in self-defense when the popcorn was thrown at him, while the state's prosecuting attorneys argue that Mr. Reeves was short-tempered and unjustified in the shooting and killing of Oulson. In the end, the jury returns a verdict of "not guilty."

June 8, 2017: In rural New Florence, Missouri, reptile breeder Benjamin Renick aka Ben Renick is found dead in his snake facility, surrounded by his collection of exotic snakes. Investigators first assume that he is a victim of one of his snakes, until the coroner finds a bullet shell casing at the scene. Dozens of potential suspects are investigated before finding a text chain from Ben that leads to the killer, Ben's wife, Lynlee Renick. Her ex-boyfriend, Michael Humphrey, was also arrested. After their arrests in 2020, they pointed the finger at each other. In 2022, Lynlee (the mastermind) was convicted and sentenced to 16 years in prison for her husband's murder. Also in 2022, Michael Humphrey (the gunman) was convicted and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

2018: When a young college student, Mollie Tibbetts, disappears on her evening run, investigators scour her small town searching for her. When her accused attacker takes the stand, the story becomes more complicated than expected. In the end, Cristhian Bahena Rivera is convicted of her murder and sentenced to life in prison.

Oshkosh, Wisconsin: Joshua Aide is on trial for the August 4, 2020 nighttime murder of his ex-girlfriend's father, age 59; the attempted murder of his ex-girlfriend, age 33; and the attempted murder of a family friend, age 57. Joshua was arrested a few hours after the shootings. Joshua claims he was ambushed by all three of them, and that they were plotting to kill him and obtain money by cashing in on his life insurance policy. The shootings happened after he got angry after learning that someone else was going to be working on his vehicle, a Chevrolet Tahoe, which he and his ex-girlfriend co-owned. In the end, Joshua Aide was found guilty by the jury and was sentenced to "life in prison plus 80 years, with no possibility of parole" for shooting his ex-girlfriend Rebecca Borkowski; fatally shooting her father James Gruettner; and shooting John Miller, a family friend of the Gruettners. The extra 80 years were added to Joshua's murder sentence for the two attempted murder shootings.