Quincy attends a course to try to overcome his fears, but when The Instructor goes off to get something, with Gavin in the Fear workshop and some other Fraidy pets looking up to Quincy, he must be brave.
When Edie tends to have a seemingly-endless chain of bad luck, Jade appears to have nothing but good luck, and Roxie tries to get Jade to give some of her good luck to Edie.
Jade concerns over Edie watching too many soap operas, so when Edie starts believing her friends are living the life of a soap opera, Jade sets up a scheme with the other pets so they could play along with her.
Roxie is unable to return to her home because she lost her key that she needed to return. Her friends try to cheer her up while they try to find her key.
Jade tries to stay awake for a whole day to prove to her friends that cats do more than just sleep all day, but the lack of sleep causes her to lose her mind.
Quincy wins a chance to ride on an airship with the pop star, Savannah, but it turns out to be an adventure when something goes wrong with the ship, and now, they must try to fix it.
Edie casts her friends in a play called Pet Side Story, and she discovers a shy bat who has remarkable talent and insists she play the lead in the play.
Trip's idol, Master Croaker, invites him to replace one of his martial arts frogs for their performance in Pawtucket after Trip accidentally injures him. Trip frantically tries to learn Martial Arts since he doesn't know any of it.
Edie and Gavin befriend each other when they discover they are both fans of Salty Dogs, but they both want to keep their fandom a total secret from their respective groups of friends.
Bev has a new set of aquatic friends and notices how identical they are to her real friends. She arranged to have them meet, but it turns out to be a train wreck.
Roxie is obsessed with a Paw'd Cast Called "Wool Over His Eyes", But the Final Episode takes so long to wait, so she tries to find the producers to ask them how it ends.
When a Limo Breakdown stops Edie from taking her friends to a musical she loves, Bev has an idea about a Story Stick That Everyone gets a turn to add plotlines to a fantasy story.
Bev and Roxie plan to Surprise Mister Yut for his birthday with A Savannah Cheetaby Concert, but they get the date wrong, and now Bev must go to The Chill Out Inn to find Savannah.
