A Florida man is found bleeding in his car, the victim of 4 gun shot wounds. On a nearby beach, a young woman lies dead. The husband claims he and his wife were robbed and shot, but the police bring in the most surprising suspect of all: the husband himself. Rival narratives of what happened on that dark Florida night clash in the courtroom, leaving the jury hanging in the balance. Tales of murdered pets, a rich inheritance, and violent tendencies hang like dark clouds over the trail, while testimonies from friends and family seek to influence the outcome. Will April's killer walk free, or has he already?