High profile Sevvy Johnson is found not guilty of murdering two women, and eight years later, he's suspected in his new girlfriend's murder. The former county prosecutor who lost the first case returns to try and convict Sevvy this time.
Maya and Matthew search Sevvy's house for anything that might lead to an arrest as they face mounting pressure from Wiest to build a case quickly; Ezra tries to clean up Sevvy's image.
Maya convinces an asset to wear a wire during a rendezvous with Sevvy; Ezra works to create an alibi for Sevvy and he sends his henchman, Buck, to pay a visit to Riv at his ranch.
Maya obtains surveillance footage of Jessica and Julianne the night before Jessica's death. Elsewhere, Maya finds out that there's a mole leaking information to Ezra.
The district attorney's office makes everyone take a lie detector test in an effort to find the mole feeding information to Ezra Wolf. Meanwhile, Maya receives an unexpected visit from Sevvy's son Gabe at work.
Sevvy is nowhere to be found before he is due to appear in court. Jessica Meyer's sister Lindsay meets with Maya and wants Sevvy behind bars, while the police receive a report that Maya is being stalked.
Sevvy begins to have hallucinations about his departed ex Jessica, while her disgruntled sister, Lindsay, tries to take matters into her own hands. Meanwhile, the police find a homeless man wearing a jacket that belonged to Sevvy, and things escalate with Maya's stalker.
The district attorney's office is determined to get to the bottom of newfound evidence that appears to be planted. The police give Maya a security detail after the case takes a dangerous turn, while Loni comes clean to Maya about her dealings with Ezra.