When beloved high school baseball coach, Russ Stager marries his loving, church-going wife Barbara he thinks he has the perfect life. But he soon discovers her obsessive lies and torrid affair and his whole life begins to crumble. As a devoted husband, Russ is determined to make the marriage work. He forgives her, which proves to be a very deadly mistake. In the early morning darkness, a gun beneath a pillow is discharged and Russ is fatally shot in the head. Barbara tells police it was a terrible accident, but is this another one of Barbara's lies? A deep dark secret from her past could be the key to uncovering the truth.