Disheartened with relationships and always foreseeing how things end, Maggie's life is forever changed when she has a prediction she didn't see coming.
As Maggie struggles to offer hope to a client, Ben and Jessie's new presence in the duplex pushes her to move her psychic business out of her home and into a local storefront, where she meets a potential new love interest.
A tentative Maggie is coerced into a double date by Louise with Daniel and John. After the double date, Louise breaks things off with John based on a face Maggie made while having a vision.
Maggie mentors a teenager who's just started having visions, which leads to conflict between Maggie and her mother as Maggie reflects on her own teen years. Amy hits Louise's car and goes overboard trying to make it up to her.
Maggie's pursuit of a vision involving Ben causes Amy and Dave to get addicted to her readings. Meanwhile, Ben struggles to find joy going through boxes from his childhood with Jessie and Louise.
Maggie grapples with putting herself out there at her job. Without a sign or any advertisement at her storefront, she gets countless confused walk-ins and must overcome her fears of owning who she is.
Maggie is excited to receive an invitation to a fancy gathering for mystics only. Meanwhile, Louise hands over control of her dating apps to Jessie, Ben, Amy and Dave.
It's been a week since Maggie lost her visions and she hasn't gotten any clarity. Desperate, she goes through the stages of grief and tries everything she can to get them back.
Having accepted the loss of her visions, Maggie looks forward to Amy and Dave's wedding. But everything goes downhill at the rehearsal dinner when Jessie reveals that she knows the secret the whole group has been hiding.
