Near-silent and shot via a cell phone, a war veteran observes the world which has been colored by his experiences in Afghanistan.
Cyrus Frisch has been called the 'enfant terrible' of Dutch filmmaking. In Why Didn't Anybody Tell Me It Would Become This Bad in Afghanistan, Frisch stars as the protagonist of his own movie, playing an emotionally withdrawn veteran of the war in Afghanistan who observes the world in increasing isolation from the window of his apartment in Amsterdam, and from disembodied angles as he wanders the streets of the city. His eye is instinctively drawn to the escalating harassment of the immigrant population by the police. Throughout the film, Frisch highlights the global loss of multicultural understanding in discomfiting fashion. His filmmaking style is nothing less than bravura. Shooting entirely through a cell phone, he constructs an essentially dialogue-free, improvisational narrative. The protagonist's isolation from his surroundings is underscored by bars on his apartment's windows that frame the immigrants on the outside, who are themselves imprisoned in an increasingly alien culture. At other moments, Frisch turns the camera on himself, his mind's eye reflecting back to violent flashes of war. Throughout the film, figurative images of people in the street below, the play of light on the water of the canals, shots of buildings against the setting sun and scenes of people in landscapes tend to break up into digital pixels, and blur and bleed into blotches of vivid, colorful abstraction. An experimental narrative par-extraordinaire, this film is reminiscent of Jennifer Reeves' The Time We Killed (Tribeca Film Festival 2004), an avant-garde feature film detailing the disturbing effects of September 11 on the psyche of the main protagonist.—Jon Gartenberg
Told through the eyes of a traumatized Dutch soldier who has returned home from a tour of Afghanistan, Why didn't anybody. . . documents the brewing tensions between native Dutch citizenry, immigrant youth and the police in a small square in the heart of Amsterdam. In this decidedly experimental work, shot almost entirely with a cell phone video camera, these tensions are made palpable through a process of accumulation. Scene after scene of youths gathering, police detentions and aimless protests are lensed from a claustrophobic, subjective viewpoint. The film also happens to be the first feature-length work shot on a cell phone to screen at the Rotterdam International Film Festival, making it the first such work to premiere at any international festival of prestige worldwide. In itself, this represents a major accomplishment, but more importantly it recharges the first-person narrative with startling intensity. Director Cyrus Frisch uses the qualities of the cell phone-its degraded video quality, its mobility, its unique cultural standing as both a public and private tool for communication-to imbue his film with themes of intense subjectivity, alienated paranoia and the immediacy of documentary. Frisch notes, "There is a lot of fear about war, the environment and the economy, and this is projected onto something smaller that we can cope with, like immigrant kids in our streets. But, at the end of the day, I think it is understandable and even healthy that we feel insecure about our future."—Sean Uyehara
Director's Statement about the origin of 'Why Didn't Anybody Tell Me It Would Become This Bad in Afghanistan'. A war veteran once told me: "When I leave my house to go shopping, I always feel I have to go back and put on my helmet and fighting gear, even though I know this to be nonsense." In the ten years that I've been living on this charming little square in the heart of Amsterdam, I've seen the atmosphere become more and more aggressive. A growing number of youth of immigrant origins ('foreigners') use this place as a hangout. The residents eye them with concern. The teens demand that they be treated with respect, while the predominantly white residents feel they ought to earn that respect. These different expectations give rise to a lot of misunderstandings and rows. It creates a growing tension that is completely unnecessary and wouldn't exist if the parties involved were to approach each other with a little more tact and circumspection. The residents demand the police to take firmer action. And the police officers comply. Almost imperceptibly, they interfere more frequently and more forcefully every day. It was out of a feeling of compassion with the belittling or outright aggressive and intolerant way these kids are being treated, that two years ago I decided to try and capture this alarming development with the camera of my mobile phone. For lots of reasons it seemed logical to me to make these images into the observations of an Afghanistan veteran. The most important of these is that his past makes it believable that he feels threatened, even if in fact not much, or nothing is going on. I see a lot of fear in our society. I think that fear is understandable, and that it has to do with the shift of economic power from the West to Asia. And with the question what that will mean for geopolitics and the environment. Uncertainties that are so intractably large that they are hard to comprehend and subsume under our powers of imagination. In an attempt to make them smaller and more manageable, we therefore blame everything on the youth of foreign extraction. Anyway, that's how I see it. To me 'Why Didn't Anybody Tell Me It Would Become This Bad in Afghanistan' is an appeal for us to act less paranoid. Cyrus Frisch, December 2006.