While closing down his bed-and-breakfast for the season, Sam is surprised by two women who have checked themselves in "just for a night or two." He decides to let them stay but asks for one odd favor in return.

Two women arrive unannounced at a bed and breakfast in hopes of finding a location for next year's family reunion. The two best friends are greeted by Sam, the owner, informing them he's closed for the season. Using their wit, Carol and J.L. convince Sam to stay open a day or two longer, just for them. While getting to know each other Sam expresses his distaste for previous guests who constantly talk about themselves and their pasts. Carol empathizes with Sam's weariness and quickly agrees not to talk about herself. Meanwhile, J.L. becomes more and more frustrated with Sam's guarded personality and secretive life. A whirlwind of hostility, manipulation, and discomfort kicks-up as J.L. begins to suspect her best friend is forming an inappropriate bond with Sam.