An underground trivia legend in NYC lives in the shadows. He faces a mysterious unbeaten game show from his past when he battles his rival to reclaim the greatness he once had.

Obsessive trivia buff Scott Nadler is living hand-to-mouth off pub quiz payouts when the unbeaten game show "Trivia Night" announces its sendoff episode will resurrect a single past contestant. As he navigates the shrewd qualifying rounds for the show that once embarrassingly eliminated him, Scott combats a rival from the past who may be the only person who can outmaneuver him.