Zoey Miller, a super smart computer nerd who is uninterested in romantic love, has her life turned upside down when Zack, the school's soccer star, gets amnesia and mistakes Zoey for his girlfriend.

Zoey Miller (Josephine Langford), a super smart college student who is uninterested in romantic love, has her life turned upside down when Zach (Drew Starkey), the captain of the boys' soccer team, gets amnesia and mistakes Zoey for his girlfriend. In an attempt to get closer to Zach's cousin Miles (Archie Renaux), a grad student who shares similar intellectual interests to Zoey, she joins his family on a ski trip for the weekend pretending to be Zach's girlfriend. Caught in between the two men while maintaining the girlfriend facade, her determination to look for compatibility as opposed to romantic love begins to falter.

When Zoey (Josephine Langford), a smart computer nerd inexperienced with love, causes Zach (Drew Starkey) to get a concussion, he mistakes Zoey for his girlfriend. Before she reveals the truth, she meets Zach's cousin Miles (Archie Renaux), with whom she has a lot in common. Pretending to be Zach's girlfriend, she realizes she has feelings for both of them and is forced to confront her fears and to make an impossible decision!