Three friends roast marshmallows in the woods. During a scary story, they are watched, and each friend disappears while investigating the noises coming from the shadows...

Steven, Tori, and Chris go camping in the woods. While they roast marshmallows and make s'mores, Tori tells a scary story about a cannibal who raised a wolf pup to love the taste of human flesh. The wolf turned on him and ate him. As the story is being told, a mysterious creature watches the friends from the shadows. Hearing the noises it makes, first Chris, then Steven go to investigate. Neither returns, leaving Tori alone. She hears the noise again. Upon investigating, she is beset upon by the creature. However, the creature was never after the friends. When it snatches the bag of marshmallows in the end, it is revealed that the creature was always only interested in eating their marshmallows.—Chiara Farina