A reality TV star leaves Hollywood and finds herself in Amish country where she must decide between staying in her newfound reality or returning to her old one.

Ann moved to Los Angeles to work in catering but instead became a reality star in a show that depicts her relationship with the star Scott. However, the ratings are declining, and the production company and Scott want to fix it by having Scott date another girl and move Ann behind the scenes. Ann, who thought Scott would propose, becomes angry and upset and sneaks away to go home to Pennsylvania. On the way there, she crashes into a ditch and ends up stranded in an Amish town. She is taken in at a small B&B and soon meets Hunter, who works in the town. Meanwhile, the production company has realized that the audience wants Ann back and starts looking for her.