An anonymous suitor sends optometrist Sarah a gift for each night of Hanukkah. As she tries to find her secret admirer, she learns that her one true love might be someone she never expected.

Optometrist Sarah's childhood friend Daniel helps her fix up her clinic. He follows her dating life with interest as she tries to date two different guys, Adam and Tom, at the same time that her ex-husband Nigel reappears with signs of regretting their divorce. Hanukkah comes and she receives one perfect gift for each of the eight nights of the celebration. But who is sending these mysterious gifts? Which of her suitors knows her so well?—Johan Hammar