Kelly Brooks is an elementary school teacher who gave up on love during the holiday season until her childhood friend Andrew a professional baseball player returns home to win Kelly's heart for Christmas.

When Ahmad visits his family in Myrtle Beach for Christmas, he realizes his family needs his help the most. His cousin Camilla is suspecting her husband Maison wants a divorce for Christmas - she seeks advice in ways to save her marriage. Ahmad's cousin, Andrew is a professional baseball player in Myrtle Beach and has feelings for his college sweetheart Kelly who is a teacher in the same city. Kelly is reluctant in seeing Andrew because she remembers the way things ended between them. Kelly's friend Tyler who is also friends with Andrew encourages Kelly to give Andrew a second chance for Christmas. Tyler reminds Kelly on all the good things that she and Andrew had together. Crystal wants for Christmas is a baby which is top on her list. Crystal's husband Chris wants to wait because he remembers the pain of losing their child and wants to make sure they are ready. Crystal's friend Monica visits for Christmas and brings her opinionated associate Evan to meet the family. Monica wants to be in a relationship for Christmas, so Crystal suggests that she dumps Evan and wait for the right man to come along.