- Colby Lopez
- Seth Rollins
- AJ Styles
- AJ Styles
- Kofi Kingston
- Kofi Kingston
- Kevin Steen
- Kevin Owens
- Brock Lesnar
- Brock Lesnar - Men's MITB winner
- Adeel Alam
- Ali
- Fergal Devitt
- Finn Bálor
- Drew McIntyre
- Drew McIntyre
- Tom Pestock
- Baron Corbin
- Randy Orton
- Randy Orton
- Trevor Mann
- Ricochet
- Manny Andrade
- Andrade
- Joe Anoa'i
- Roman Reigns
- Pamela Martinez
- Bayley - Women's MITB winner
- Rebecca Quin
- Becky Lynch
- Jeff Sciullo
- Elias
- Ashley Fliehr
- Charlotte
- Macey Estrella
- Lacey Evans
- Nattie Neidhart
- Natalya
- Trinity McCray Fatu
- Naomi
- Ashley Mae Sebera
- Dana Brooke
- Adrienne Reese
- Ember Moon
- Nicola Glencross
- Nikki Cross
- Amanda Saccomanno
- Mandy Rose
- Ariya Daivari
- Ariya Daivari
- Shane McMahon
- Self
- Mike 'The Miz' Mizanin
- The Miz
- Rey Mysterio
- Rey Mysterio
- Anthony Nese
- Tony Nese
- Joe Seanoa
- Samoa Joe
- Daria Berenato
- Sonya Deville
- Bryan Danielson
- Daniel Bryan
- Jonathan Solofa Fatu
- Jimmy Uso
- Joshua Samuel Fatu
- Jey Uso
- Paul Heyman
- Paul Heyman
- Lexi Kaufman
- Alexa Bliss
- Dylan Miley
- Lars Sullivan
- Emanuel Rodriguez
- Kalisto
- Joseph Ruud
- Rowan
- Adam Scherr
- Braun Strowman
- Thea Trinidad
- Zelina Vega
- Leah Van Dale
- Carmella
