- Raychael Lane
- Sophia
- Chase Crawford
- Noah
- Leonardo Mancini
- Trey
- La'Rayja Hill
- Malecia
- Laura Lynn
- Theresa
- KateLynn E. Newberry
- Madison Fatchek
- Devito Parker Jr.
- RJ
- Wuyu Wantatah
- Rayjon
- Rick Montgomery Jr.
- Grandpa
- Craig Brophy
- Santa
- Fran Pulford
- Grandma
- Giovanni Chechitelli
- Neighbor Kid 1
- Elijah Chechitelli
- Neighbor Kid 2
- Rachel Anderson
- Becky Manfredo
- Shba Cochrane
- Mail Carrier
- Derek Steyer
- Todd Kapoppy
- Branislav R. Tatalovic
- Mayor McHenry
- Evette Smith-Parker
- Neighbor Lady
- David Solomon Abrams
- Deputy Spisak
- Bunnie Ferro
- Ingrid
- Lex Godoy
- Guy Sanders
- Marsel Hajdari
- Deputy Gritz
- Scot Teller
- Deputy Stony
- Jon Huff
- Deputy Stubbs
- Jason Klingensmith
- Deputy Wilson
- Jeff Grant
- Deputy Figinski
- John Tkach
- Deputy Tuccolo
- Eric Wilhelm
- Weatherman Stan
- Jess Byard
- Arcade Extra 1
- Joe Morales
- Mynie Moe
- Chloe Klotz
- Eenie Meanie
- Jonny Smail
- Smail (animated sequence) / Arcade Game Player 1 (Extra) (as Jon Smail)
- Dallas Bigley
- Arcade Patron (Extra)
- Evette Parker
- Neighbor Lady
- Ed Frame
- Pastor
- Paul Gustovich
- Creepy Pharmacist
- Kodie Ferro
- Fast Food Worker (Extra)
- DeJeanu Adams
- Elf 2
- Nick Adduci
- Choir Member (Extra)
- Blanco Aleguar
- Sportscaster Chip
- Jimmy Barber Sr.
- Choir Member (Extra)
- Kim Carney
- Choir Member (Extra)
- Marissa Cashbaugh
- Choir Member (Extra)
- John Catheline
- Church Member
- Liano Chechitelli
- Crying Baby 2
- Ellen W. Conrad
- Christmas Caroler
- Diablo
- The Iguana
- Cindy Castro DiRusso
- Church Member (Extra)
- Jeff A. Engalder
- Church Member (Extra)
- Louie B. Free
- Wacky Neighbor
- Issy Greathouse
- Elf 1
- Sarah Gustwiller
- Christmas Caroler
- Kelly Jackson
- Upset Mother 2
- Brandy Johanntges
- Talk Radio Woman
- Ashley Lynn Johnson
- Church Member (Extra)
- Greg Kraus
- Bowler (Extra)
- Daniel Lamont
- Church Member (Extra)
- Courtney Lundgren
- Church Member (Extra)
- Kenneth L. Martin
- Christmas Caroler
- Paul Martin
- Daddy Spisak
- Paul Martin
- Daddy spasiac
- Shayna McConahay
- Choir Member (Extra)
- Jonathan Metz
- Bubble Blower
- Chip Miklas
- Mall Patron (Extra)
- Olivia Miklas
- Crying Baby 1
- Monica Miles
- Young Grandma
- Austin Miller
- Teen on Phone
- Jada Miller
- Church Member (Extra)
- Charles J. Muszik Jr.
- Church Member (Extra)
- Mike Newman
- Christmas Caroler
- Bradley Noble
- Young Grandpa
- Sean Pakos
- Church Member (Extra)
- Rayna Perdue
- Dream Girl
- Danielle Putnam
- Church Member (Extra)
- Ryan M. Simpson
- Church Member (Extra)
- Ed Springfield
- Sportscaster Rick
- Chrystal Star
- Choir Member (Extra)
- Stephanie Stearns
- Choir Member (Extra)
- Lexi Sudac
- Teen with Attitude
- Lindsay Tuttle
- Upset Mother 1
- Joseph Vaglica
- Mall Manager
- Angeliyah Webster
- Choir Member (Extra)
- Heidi Wlodarski
- Choir Member (Extra)
- Paul Worley
- Church Member (Extra)
