- Antonio Burke Jr.
- Antonio Banks
- Charles Cardwell
- Mr. Milo Beasley - DP Associates
- Kory Chavis
- Rainman
- Jerrelle Clark
- Self
- Scott Colton
- Colt Cabana
- Phil Davis
- Self - The Heartbreak Express
- Sean Davis
- Self - The Heartbreak Express
- Kevin Dunn
- Dunn - The Ring Crew Express
- Jay Fury
- Self
- James Guffey
- Jimmy Rave - DP Associates
- Brian Kendrick
- Spanky
- Tony Kozina
- Self
- Lenny Leonard
- Self - commentator
- Chris Lindsey
- Roderick Strong
- Steve Madison
- Self
- Kirby Marcos
- Marcos - The Ring Crew Express
- Federico Palacios
- Azrieal - The New Dawn
- Dave Prazak
- Self - DP Associates / commentator
- CM Punk
- C.M. Punk - The New Dawn / DP Associates (as C.M. Punk)
- Sal Rinauro
- Self
- Joe Seanoa
- Samoa Joe - The New Dawn / DP Associates
- Charles Spencer
- Tony Mamaluke
- Jared Steele
- Self
- Chris Valenzuela
- Don Juan
- Eddie Villa
- Fast Eddie Vegas - DP Associates
