- Michael Zuccola
- David Whitmer
- Caleb J. Spivak
- Oliver Cowdery
- Lincoln Hoppe
- Martin Harris
- Paul Wuthrich
- Joseph Smith Jr.
- Jill Adler
- Lucy Harris Friend #1
- Jack Agnew
- Messenger
- Herbie Aitken
- Silas' Friend
- Austen Alexander
- Silas
- Geoffrey Allen
- Bishop
- Mateo Philip Arnold
- Mormon
- Dalton Baker
- Samuel Smith
- Spencer Barber
- Christian Whitmer
- Emerson Beckham
- Baseball Boy
- Joel Bishop
- Joseph Smith, Sr.
- Charla Bocchicchio
- Mary Whitmer
- Jane Bradley
- Lucy Harris Friend #3
- Lily Brady
- Harris Child #2
- Stephanie Breinholt
- Lucy Mack Smith
- Mike Brown
- Harmony Attacker #1
- Peter Brownlee
- Mormon
- Byron Brydges
- Pistol Waving Man
- Connor Burt
- Harris Child #4
- Pat Cannon
- Harmony Attacker #2
- Joseph Carlson
- Sidney Rigdon
- Ted Charette
- Edwin Kelly
- Nicholas Chieffo
- Attacker #1
- Scott Christopher
- Peter Whitmer, Sr.
- Jason Clarke
- Faithful Man #2
- James Connally
- Iowa Man
- Arthur Cummins
- Don Carlos Smith
- Ken Curtis
- Hooligan #5
- Mark Dancewicz
- Orson Hyde
- Dennis Daniel
- Crowd
- Skyler M. Day
- Woman in Kitchen
- Zenek de Savigny
- David Whitmer, Jr. (5 years old)
- Ryan Echlin
- Hooligan #4
- Aaron Fielding
- Treasure Man #1
- Cam Findley
- William Smith
- Dan Fowlkes
- Hooligan #1
- Camrey Bagley Fox
- Emma Smith
- Jason Gaignard
- Stephen Burnett
- Craig Gregersen
- Faithful Man #1
- Morgan Gunter
- Newell Knight
- Jason Harley
- Warren Parrish
- Levi Judson Harris
- Heber C. Kimball
- Seven Harrison
- Townsperson
- Lacy Hartselle
- Julia Whitmer
- Addyson Hawk
- Maria Cowdery
- Scarlett Hazen
- Lucy Smith
- Landon Henneman
- Defense Attorney
- William Joseph Holtby
- Parley Pratt
- Zac Hursch
- Hooligan #2
- Zach Hursh
- Hooligan #2
- Tony Ionno
- Mormon
- Danny James
- Mob Leader
- Paul Kandarian
- David Whitmer (older)
- Mark Koufos
- Peter Whitmer, Jr.
- Bennett Langdon
- Teen Boy
- Jared Larkin
- Witness #1
- Tanner Lush
- Printer Mob Ruffian
- Tanner Lush
- Printer Mob Ruffian
- Mason Mac
- Hyrum Smith
- Eb Madson
- David Holbrook
- Louise Mara
- Waitress
- William McAllister
- Martin Harris Neighbor #3
- Dallin McKay
- William Smith
- Matt McLaughlin
- Dissident
- Chipper Meyer
- Martin Harris Neighbor #4
- Korbin Middleton
- Baseball Boy
- Crystal Myler
- Townsperson
- Skylar Neale
- Andy's Friend
- Gemma Nye
- Harris Child #3
- Karldon Okruta
- Frederick G. Williams
- Catherine Olsen
- Townspeople
- Rebecca Olson
- Midwife
- Shaun Parry
- Attacker #3
- Annie Pasmann
- Katherine Smith
- Dave Peterson
- Bailiff
- Jyllian Petrie
- Lucy Harris
- Vicky Piercey
- Martin Harris Neighbor #1
- Alexander Platt
- Christian Whitmer
- Jacob Richman
- John Boynton
- Jordan Sawyer
- William Smith
- Stevie Schaeffer
- Catherine Whitmer
- Darin Scott
- Luke Johnson
- Duane Stephens
- Prosecutor
- Shawn Stevens
- Judge Tiffany
- Elliotte Stewart
- Alvin Smith (newborn)
- Lue Stirland
- Baseball Boy
- Cora Stone
- Harris Child #1
- Frederik Storm
- Hooligan #3
- Frederik Storm
- Hooligan #3
- Amanda Taylor
- Lucy Harris Friend #2
- Brittany Thomas
- Martin Harris Neighbor #2
- Samantha Rose Valletta
- Elizabeth Cowdery
- Jack Wright
- David Whitmer, Jr. (18 months)
- Colin Wylie
- Sign Painter
- Zachary Zamsky
- Treasure Man #2
- Jerome Brad Halgren
- a Judge and a Juror
