- Molly Shannon
- Emily Dickinson
- Susan Ziegler
- Susan Dickinson
- Amy Seimetz
- Mabel Todd
- Brett Gelman
- Col. Thomas Wentworth Higginson
- Jackie Monahan
- Lavina Dickinson
- Kevin Seal
- Austin Dickinson
- Dana Melanie
- Young Emily
- Sasha Frolova
- Young Susan
- Lisa Haas
- Maggie
- Stella Chesnut
- Mattie Dickinson
- Guinevere Turner
- Elizabeth Holland
- Michael Churven
- Josiah Holland
- Robert McCaskill
- Ralph Waldo Emerson
- Lauren Modiano
- Adult Mattie Dickinson
- Al Sutton
- Judge Lord
- John Peña Griswold
- Young Austin
- Allison Lane
- The Widow Kate
- Margot Kistler
- Young Lavinia
- Cynthia Kaplan
- Helen Hunt Jackson
- Charles Rogers
- Samuel Bowles Jr.
- Derrick T. Tuggle
- Questioning Soldier
- Cole Escola
- Dweeby Reader
- Celeste Pechous
- Emily Norcross
- Joel Michaely
- Edward Dickinson
- Rae C. Wright
- Head Shakespeare Lady
- Lee Eaton
- Parson Mudd
- Katherine Willard
- Clara Newman Turner / Whist Party Player
- Nick A. Fisher
- Gilbert 'Gib' Dickinson
- Nolan Chestnut
- Ned Dickinson
- Christian Izziary
- Adult Ned
- Sally Sockwell
- Abby Farley / Wedding Guest / Shakespeare Reading Society
- David Albiero
- David Peck Todd
- Betsy Farrell
- Amhurst Lady 1 / Shakespeare Reading Society
- Casper Andreas
- Joseph Lyman
- Barbara Davy
- Amherst Lady 2 / Shakespeare Reading Society
- Marc Alan Austen
- Distinguished Party Guest
- Morna Ryan
- Wedding Guest
- Matthew R. Ossenfort
- Wedding Guest
- Ron Lynch
- Ophthalmologist
- David Meyers
- Emerson Party Guest
- Stacey Alyse Cohen
- Tea Lady
- Brittini Schreiber
- Tea Lady
- Kathleen Wilce
- Tea Lady
- Melissa Barton Ryan
- Tea Lady
- Pan Ferguson
- Tea Lady
- Elaine Carberry
- Tea Lady
- Anna La Roche
- Tea Lady
- Alina Cherednychenko
- Tea Lady
- Caitlin Rodstein
- Tea Lady
- Linda Vega
- Tea Lady
- Rowann Gilman
- Tea Lady
- Samantha Pascale
- Tea Lady
- Sofia Seneca
- Tea Lady
- Carolina Parra Moreno
- Tea Lady
- Carolina Parra
- Tea Lady
- Freia Serafina
- Tea Lady
- Holly Battaglia
- Tea Lady
- Kathleen Tawney
- Tea Lady
- Nathalie Baer Chan
- Tea Lady
- Jo-Ann B. Victor
- Tea Lady
- Camelia Cassin
- Tea Lady
- Kasey Roren
- Tea Lady
- Julia Drahos
- Tea Lady
- Stephanie Sparks
- Tea Lady
- Katie Contini
- Tea Lady
- Betsy Winslow
- Tea Lady
- Carmen Cooper
- Tea Lady
- Katrina Mattson
- Tea Lady
- Bailie de Lacy
- Tea Lady
- Jacqueline Braslow
- Shakespeare Reading Society
- Annie Pisapia
- Tea Lady
- Austin Kase
- Wedding Guest
- Jeffery Denke
- Wedding Guest
- Frank Berman
- Wedding Guest
- Jay Olnek
- Whist Party Player
- Lisa Franklin
- Whist Party Player
- Khaliel Abdelrahei
- The First South Carolina Volunteers Amy Regiment
- Adrian Knight
- The First South Carolina Volunteers Amy Regiment
- Darren Lee Campbell
- Soldier / The First South Carolina Volunteers Amy Regiment (as Darren Campbell)
- Lulu Benamor
- Dog
- Courtney Denk
- Weeping Lady
- Elizabeth Everett
- Crying Girl
- Carmine Giordano
- Conference Attendee
- Jason Hewitt
- Dancer at Party
- Sharon Litwinoff
- Academic
- Christine McCann
- Crying Woman
- Katie Osborn
- Funeral Mourner
- Miranda Plant Byers
- Panelist at Conference
- Athena Rem
- Athena
- Jeremy Shane
- Doctor
- Tim Snoha
- Party Attendee
- Jack Taylor Jr.
- Soldier
- Kristen Misthopoulos
- Literary Party Guest
