- Charles Farrell
- Billy - the Stranger
- Joan Bennett
- Salomy Jane
- Ralph Bellamy
- Jack Marbury
- Eugene Pallette
- Yuba Bill
- Irving Pichel
- Rufe Waters
- Minna Gombell
- Millie
- Willard Robertson
- Red Pete
- Sarah Padden
- Lize
- Morgan Wallace
- Phineas Baldwin
- Louise Beavers
- Mammy Lou
- Stanley Blystone
- Deputy
- Milton Brown
- Vigilante
- Buck Bucko
- Vigilante
- Roy Bucko
- Vigilante
- Iron Eyes Cody
- Indian
- Edward Coxen
- Vigilante
- James Durkin
- Madison Clay
- Alphonse Ethier
- Sheriff
- Mary Gordon
- Washerwoman
- Marilyn Harris
- Anna May
- Robert Homans
- Sheriff / Gambling Kibitzer (uncredited)
- Carmencita Johnson
- Mary Ann
- Edmund Jones
- Vigilante
- Gordon Jones
- Vigilante
- Murdock MacQuarrie
- Jess Larabee
- Ferdinand Munier
- Colonel Starbottle
- Ralph L. Novarro
- Unidentified secondary role
- Jack Padjan
- Posse Member
- Chet Ryan
- Cowboy
- George Sowards
- Hangman
- Will Stanton
- Bartender
- Elaine Von
- Red Pete's Child
- Delmar Watson
- Willie - Red Pete's Boy
- Garry Watson
- Red Pete's Child
- Bill Wilson
- Vigilante
