- Anna Margaret Hollyman
- Suzanne / wife
- Kim Park
- Greta / Tom's wife
- Nathan Williams
- Jeff / husband
- Lydia Hyslop
- Patti / George's wife (as Lydia Johnson)
- Joe Swanberg
- George / Suzanne's neighbor
- Laura Lemar-Goldsborough
- Autumn(Fantasia) / Jeff's lover
- Leo Erickson
- Mr. Boxter / Suzanne's Father
- Yvonne Erickson
- Mrs. Boxter / Suzanne's Mother
- Tom Neubauer
- Priest
- Mark Boyett
- Tom / Jeff's friend
- Ellie Nicoll
- Barbara / Realtor
- Mahoghany Ayot Eerised
- Tricia / Realtor
- Jiyoung Lee
- Dianne / Realtor
- Melodie Sisk
- Sweater Model
- Ray Converse
- Chubby
- Marissa Molnar
- Latifa
- Chris Doubek
- Ross / Detective
- Fernanda Tapia
- Fresca
- Sydney Alexander
- Sophie
- Ayesis Clay
- Eunice / Fantasia's Mother
- Tony Greenberg
- Gene
- Maggie Ross
- Grocery Store Clerk
- Allen Brooks
- Security Guard
- Colleen Clark
- Macy's Co-worker
- Isaac Shedd
- Ronnie
- Evan Allgood
- Mourner
- Jerry Casagrande
- Mourner
- Kevin Clark
- Mourner
- Anthony Michael Hobbs
- Mourner
- Christopher Inlow
- Mourner
- Joan Peacock
- Mourner
- Brenda Sol
- Mourner
- Skizz Cyzyk
- Strip Club Patron / Black Cat Dancer
- Nasreen Alkhateeb
- Black Cat Dancer
- Gavriel Cotton
- Black Cat Dancer
- Andrew Doucette
- Black Cat Dancer
- Brynn Headington
- Black Cat Dancer
- Chris Holland
- Strip Club Patron
- Andrew Hylton
- Strip Club Patron
- Derek Litchfield
- Strip Club Patron
- Matt O'Grady
- Strip Club Patron / Black Cat Dancer
- Tad Peyton
- Black Cat dancer
- Dioni Rey
- Black Cat Dancer
- Mundy Spears
- Black Cat Dancer
- Joe Tropea
- Strip Club Patron
- Tommy Watkins
- Black Cat Dancer
- Mitchell West
- Strip Club Patron
