- Pam Arciero
- Grundgetta / Shoes / Jacket
- Jennifer Barnhart
- Zoe / Gladys the Cow
- Tyler Bunch
- Louie / Chicken / Cat
- Leslie Carrara-Rudolph
- Abby Cadabby
- Frankie Cordero
- Rudy / Sunflower / Pig
- Stephanie D'Abruzzo
- Prairie Dawn / Gale Warning
- Justiin Davis
- Self
- Ryan Dillon
- Elmo
- Sophia DiStefano
- Girl
- Eric Jacobson
- Bert / Grover / Oscar / Guy Smiley
- John Kennedy
- Mel
- Chris Knowings
- Chris
- Peter Linz
- Ernie / Herry Monster
- Blake Lively
- Delivery Person
- Suki Lopez
- Nina
- Samantha McDanel
- Additional Muppet Performer
- Carmen Osbahr
- Rosita
- Madeleine Grace Pace
- Girl
- Martin P. Robinson
- Todd Jameson
- David Rudman
- Cookie Monster
- Amanda Seyfried
- Natalie Neptune
- Matt Vogel
- Big Bird / The Count / Mr. Johnson / The Wish Pickle
- Ilana Glazer
- Ms. Noodle
- Deborah Grausman
- Smartie
