- Phil Vischer
- Bob the Tomato / Jimmy Gourd / Percy Pea / Octavius (Mr. Lunt) / Captain (Pa Grape) / Pastor (George) (voice)
- Mike Nawrocki
- Larry the Cucumber / Dad Carrot / Jean Claude Pea (voice)
- Lisa Vischer
- Junior Asparagus
- Gigi Abraham
- Nicholas / Choir (voice)
- Alan Lee
- Gustav / Epiphanus (voice)
- Cydney Trent
- Sister Claire (Petunia)
- Megan Murphy
- Laura Carrot / Choir (voice)
- Keri Pagetta
- Tona / Choir (voice) (as Keri Pisapia)
- Ally Nawrocki
- Annie / Choir (voice)
- Kurt Heinecke
- Little Drummer Boy / Choir (voice) (as Kurt Henry Heinecke)
- J. Chris Wall
- Poor Father
- Brian Roberts
- Extras / Choir (voice) (as Brian K. Roberts)
- Joe Spadaford
- Extras
- Sarah Vorhees Wendel
- Extras
- Clayton Heinecke
- Choir
- Gretchen Heinecke
- Choir
- Wesley Heinecke
- Choir
- Torry Martin
- Choir
- Chelsea McCoy
- Choir
- John Wahba
- Choir
- Amy Grant
- (singing voice)
- Bryce Hitchcock
- (singing voice)
- Alan Paul Lee
- Gustav / Epiphanus (voice) (as Alan Lee)
- Anna Grace Stewart
- (singing voice)
- Matthew West
- (singing voice)
