- Mike Nawrocki
- Lawrence (Merry Larry) / Henry (Jean Claude) / Peach / Turnips / Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople / Choir (voice)
- Phil Vischer
- Phillip Fleagle (Bob the Tomato) / Kid Phillip / Roadie Reggie (Mr. Lunt) / Alister Cashberger (Archibald) / Miles (Phillippe) / Sam (Jimmy) / George / Pa Grape / Silly Song Announcer / Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople (voice)
- Si Robertson
- Silas the Narrator
- Anna Grace Stewart
- Christina / Soozie (voice)
- Megan Murphy
- Mrs. Netterbaum (Madame Blueberry) / Christina's Mom / Emma (voice)
- Lisa Vischer
- Junior
- Keri Pagetta
- Mrs. Crespie / Mall Kids (voice) (as Keri Pisapia)
- Cydney Trent
- Reporter (Petunia)
- Jim Poole
- Bus Driver (Scooter)
- J. Chris Wall
- Dad Tomato / Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople / Choir (voice)
- Kay Avers
- Mom Tomato
- Brian Roberts
- Krazy Kenny / Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople / Choir (voice) (as Brian K. Roberts)
- Joe Spadaford
- Construction Worker (Leo) / Jet Pilot (voice)
- Garrett Elliott
- Mall Kids
- Michael Nawrocki
- Mall Kids
- Joseph Roberts
- Mall Kids
- Maggie Roberts
- Mall Kids
- William Roberts
- Mall Kids
- Elijah Wall
- Mall Kids
- Grace Wall
- Mall Kids
- Juliette Wall
- Mall Kids
- Andrea Logan
- Mall Kids
- Rachel Curet
- Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople
- Ron Eddy
- Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople
- Adam Frick
- Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople
- Austin James
- Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople
- Melissa Murphy
- Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople / Choir (voice)
- Haverly Pennington
- Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople
- John Pfaender
- Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople / Choir (voice)
- Paul Rinkes
- Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople
- Jessica Shaw
- Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople
- Sarah Smith
- Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople / Choir (voice)
- Brittany Stephens
- Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople / Choir (voice)
- Sarah Vorhees Wendel
- Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople
- Andy Youssi
- Mall Shopkeepers, Shoppers and Townspeople
- Sara Lucas
- Choir
- Laura Neutzling
- Choir
- Lisa Bevill
- Backup Singers
- Marabeth Quinn
- Backup Singers
- Stephanie Hall Wedan
- Backup Singers
