- Blair Peyton
- Â Lester Higgins 70 episodes, 2010-2015
- Bryan Hancock
- Â Sammy Willis / ... 68 episodes, 2010-2015
- Kristin Gainey
- Â Tess Higgins 63 episodes, 2010-2015
- Ami C. Trowell
- Â Helen Higgins / ... 48 episodes, 2010-2015
- Christie Williams
- Â Delores Grace 31 episodes, 2010-2013
- Frazier Hughes
- Â Mike Vinyl 24 episodes, 2010-2014
- Kevin McAlexander
- Â Rusty Carmichael / ... 24 episodes, 2011-2015
- Kristin Banks
- Â Katie Yournicorn / ... 23 episodes, 2010-2013
- Amanda Cash
- Â Lacey Carmichael 17 episodes, 2014-2015
- Timothy Martin
- Â Trevor Powers 14 episodes, 2010-2011
- Becky May
- Â Lola Blevins / ... 11 episodes, 2010-2012
- Suzanne Rothgeb
- Â Tally Hershelstein 9 episodes, 2010
- Brianna Bogue
- Â Casey Blevins 9 episodes, 2010
- Juli Kent
- Â Babs Crowley 9 episodes, 2014-2015
- Willow Rosenblatt
- Â Willow Hershelstein 8 episodes, 2011-2014
- Stevie Holcomb
- Â Crystal 7 episodes, 2014-2015
- Deja Hatch
- Â Shelly 6 episodes, 2010-2013
- Kevin Scott
- Â William Wadsworth 6 episodes, 2010-2011
- Rob Ruthenberg
- Â Rob Hershelstein 6 episodes, 2011-2014
- M. Jason Turner
- Â Big Mo / ... 5 episodes, 2010-2014
- Amelia Roberson
- Â Edna Garrett 5 episodes, 2010
- Jeremy Meador
- Â Carlos 5 episodes, 2011
- Melissa Douty
- Â Harley Davidsen 5 episodes, 2014
- Megan Sloan White
- Â Mitzi / ... 4 episodes, 2010-2013
- Mark Page
- Â Gabriel 4 episodes, 2010-2012
- Ross Laguzza
- Â Dick Higgins 4 episodes, 2010-2012
- Amy Graybill
- Â Dina Garrett 4 episodes, 2010
- John Bryant
- Â Rick 4 episodes, 2010
- Emily Hepner-Leffel
- Â Elli May Yournicorn-Whiffel / ... 4 episodes, 2013-2014
- Rodrigue Karam
- Â Ricardo 4 episodes, 2014
- Karri Ingram
- Â Brooke Westwood 3 episodes, 2010-2012
- Stephen Glassbrenner
- Â Cousin Paulie 3 episodes, 2011-2014
- Taryn Anderson
- Â Krystal-Faye 3 episodes, 2011-2013
- Madeleine Pressley
-  Renée / ... 3 episodes, 2012-2014
- Chad Runyon
- Â Barcromb Finester-Crowley 3 episodes, 2012-2013
- Antoine Terrell
- Â Alternate Universe Sammy / ... 3 episodes, 2014-2015
- Alan Perry
- Â Pastor Popoff 2 episodes, 2011-2012
- Patrick Williams
- Â Seth 2 episodes, 2011
- Keri Kelly
- Â Applicant / ... 2 episodes, 2011
- Tony Scott
- Â Blaine 2 episodes, 2011
- Patrick Kelly
- Â Man / ... 2 episodes, 2011
- Aimee Perkins
- Â Vanessa 2 episodes, 2011
- Mike Wilson
- Â Self 2 episodes, 2012-2013
- Kris Laguzza
- Â Barbara / ... 2 episodes, 2013-2014
- Monica Wakefield
- Â Lily 2 episodes, 2013
- Jenna Decker
- Â Dr. Lucinda Babbleton 1 episode, 2010
- Monica Brooks
- Â Samantha Wackenhoff 1 episode, 2010
- Robb Rouse
- Â Larry Melvin 1 episode, 2010
- River Laker
- Â Self 1 episode, 2011
- Zack Jackson
- Â Jerry 1 episode, 2011
- Laura Tuggle Anderson
- Â Gloria 1 episode, 2011
- Danny Meyers
- Â Jack 1 episode, 2011
- Allison Swecker
- Â Toni 1 episode, 2011
- Mitchell Mason
- Â Justin Bieber 1 episode, 2011
- Peyton Plunkett
-  Chloé 1 episode, 2011
- Dettchet Mullins
- Â Becky 1 episode, 2011
- Dillon Smith
- Â Applicant 1 episode, 2011
- Ernie Chandler
- Â Agent 1 episode, 2012
- Susanna Young
- Â Samantha O'Dell 1 episode, 2012
- Heidi Steinburg
- Â Home Owner 1 episode, 2012
- Rebecca Quirk
- Â Reesey Nutterman 1 episode, 2012
- Natalie Faunce
- Â Self 1 episode, 2012
- Andrea Shreeman
- Â Reverend Ramona 1 episode, 2013
- Emma Sperka
- Â Susie 1 episode, 2013
- Sarah Anglim
- Â Mandy 1 episode, 2013
- Brian Sallade
- Â Sad Customer 1 episode, 2014
- Fred Hardin
- Â Dr. McDribble 1 episode, 2015
