- Joe Ferrell
- Joe Andrews
- Nick Aiello
- Nick Buscher
- Will Flanagan
- Will Buscher
- Jake Myers
- Thorn
- Emily Allman
- Party Guest 4
- Myles Armstrong
- Myles the Bartender
- Atra Asdou
- Chicago Boss
- Garret Bodette
- Party Guest 5
- Kevin Bretz
- Rural Bar Patron 1
- Bobby Budds
- Comedian 1
- Ben Cannon
- Triumph Coworker 2
- Heidi Cheek
- Heidi
- Brittany Culkowski
- Party Guest 6
- Matt Cunningham
- Gump's friend Matt
- John Davies
- Rural Bar Patron 2
- Lucy Flanagan
- Party Guest and Bar Patron
- Shawn Flickinger
- Triumph Coworker 3
- Jason Earl Folks
- Comedian 3
- John Griffin
- Chicago Coworker 2
- Michael Gump
- Gump
- Liz Harvey
- Liz
- Patrick Jenkins
- Party Guest 7
- Liz Kaar
- Curler 1
- Ben Kobold
- Cab driver
- Bryan Kveton
- Party Guest 8
- Leland
- Dog
- Dan Lindorfer
- Party Guest 9
- Garrett Luczak
- Party Guest 1
- Ben Magnuson
- Chicago Coworker 1
- Eli Coyote Mandel
- Triumph Coworker 1
- Amanda Mobley
- Chicago Coworker 3
- Jeremiah Myers
- Curler and Party Guest
- John Myers
- John Buscher
- Josh Myers
- Triumph Boss
- Casey Ochs
- Party Guest 2
- Colin Ochs
- Party Guest 3
- Cory Ryan
- Cory from Sanitation
- Meghan Shanahan
- Megan
- Tyler Snodgrass
- Comedian 2
- Aaron Stone
- Ice Cream Boy
- Laurel Stone
- Ice Cream Mom
- Toni Van Laarhoven
- Nick & Will's Aunt
- Traci Van Laarhoven-Myers
- Mrs. Buscher
