- Mia Arreola
- Andi Frightley
- Emma-Presley Prieto
- Grimmy
- Sadie Lynn Stroderd
- Clarity
- Alina Brielle Cano
- Bogie / Ensemble
- Brandon Lee Camarena
- Dad / Lou
- Jorja Miraldes
- Mom / Penelope
- Skyler Carreon
- Dr. Mori / Grim
- Annalia Peterson
- Ms. Cascabel / Letheria / Ensemble
- Lordyn Sepesy Pajerski
- Carla / Angela / Ensemble
- Angelica Santos
- Max / Ollie the Cat / Ensemble
- Aiko Doub
- Cain / Andi's Old Friend
- Daniela Montemayor
- Kira / Andi's Old Friend
- Rianne Anderson
- Chelsea / Contract Demon / Ensemble
- Chiara Colette Meza
- Camera Operator Demon / Ensemble
- Presley Anderson
- Make Up Artist Demon / Ensemble
