- John Goodman
- Santa Claus
- Chris Kattan
- Sparky
- Ethan Suplee
- Jingle
- Dylan Minnette
- Iggy Thistlewhite
- Eddie Griffin
- Jingle
- Delta Burke
- Mrs. Claus
- Harvey Fierstein
- Heat Miser
- Marcus Lyle Brown
- Officer Jefferson
- Michael McKean
- Snow Miser
- Aaron Beelner
- Ring Announcer
- Jody Thompson
- Clop
- Andrea Powell
- Julie Kadlubowski-Sanchez
- Matthew Carroll
- Dog catcher
- Robert C. Treveiler
- Mayor Thistlewhite
- Carol Kane
- Mother Nature
- Jack Watkins
- Boothe
- Laura Schlessinger
- Dr. Laura Schlessinger
- Todd Terry
- Wilkes
- Jack LaLanne
- Hercules
- Eric Gipson
- Power Elf #1
- Carson Kressley
- Elf Costumer
- Tina Parker
- Artemis
- Namaiya Cunningham
- Toddler at festival
- Fred Ellis
- Drunk santa
- Odessa Feaster
- Reporter
- Maggie Myatt
- Passing Woman
- Anne Quackenbush
- Teacher
- Kyle Register
- Elf
- Amanda Smoak Weisner
- Heat Miser Boxing Fan
- Hunter Ballard
- School Boy
- Austin Barton
- Boy in Gift Wrap Booth
- Barry Barton
- Gift Wrap Booth Owner
- David Blackwell
- Dr. Broadbeam
- Dodie Brown
- Festival booth owner
- Rendell Bryce
- Townsman
- Andrei Constantinescu
- Snow Miser Fan
- Mellinda Craig
- Wife of Officer Varmit
- Meagan Crews
- Izzy's friend
- Kip Cummings
- Reporter
- Brooke Devenney
- Craft booth worker in festival
- Laine Dubroc
- Festival Goer
- Dustin Estis
- North Pole Elf
- Dorcas Everette
- (uncredited)
- Travis Fontenot
- Festival Goer
- Chris Freihofer
- Sparky's Attorney
- Lara Grice
- Rachel Thistlewhite
- Mya Holloway
- Toddler girl in snow at festival
- Rebecca Holloway
- Mom at arcade - Token Town
- Deborah R. Jones
- Journalist
- Lori Knighton
- Festival visitor
- Tyler Krieg
- Extra
- Daniel Lachman
- Southtown Citizen
- Amber Dawn Landrum
- Blonde Jingle Jangle Girl
- Chelsea Lewis
- Girl at festival
- Daniel Magill
- Elf
- Mike Martindale
- Festival / Restaurant Patron (uncredited)
- John McConnell
- Dog catcher
- Yolanda Mercadel
- John Goodmen / Eddie Grifin (uncredited)
- Steven Miramontz
- Pinstripe Elf
- Noelle Monteleone
- Gleam
- Rebecca Newman
- Festival shopper
- Desi Page
- Student
- Desiree Page
- Student
- Ashley-Anne Parker
- Token Town Employee / Festival Patron (uncredited)
- Cynthia Riser
- Reporter
- Billy Slaughter
- Nerd Elf
- Lana Underwood
- Female tv reporter
- Taylor Vosbury
- Girl Student
- Tracey Walter
- Abominable Snowman
- Maya Waterman
- Medusa
- Brent Weisner
- Snow Miser Boxing Fan
- Cheryl Ariaz Wicker
- Elf
- Lesley Wright
- Girl in Stocking Booth
