- Zack Beyer
- Sultan Al-Kamil
- Jeremy Irons
- Narrator
- Alexander McPherson
- St. Francis of Assisi
- Patrick Boyer
- German Soldier
- Eric Kramer
- Cardinal Pelagius
- Samuel Muriithi
- General
- Erik Soulliard
- Oliver of Paderborn
- Richard El Khazen
- Lieutenant
- Peter Muggleworth
- Patriarch of Constantinople
- Elliott Bales
- Pope Urban II
- Steven Soto
- Muslim General
- David Millstone
- Komnenos' Advisor
- Tony Barber
- Peasant Crusader
- Bob Schwartz
- Jewish Father
- Phil Amico
- Pope Innocent III
- Julio Bana Fernandez
- Tavern patron
- Moses Bernal
- Field Doctor
- Alexander Demah
- Leader of the Mob
- Chris Dinolfo
- Francis' Friend #1
- Ava Edwards
- Peasant Crusader's Daughter
- Robert Rivera Fairman
- Impaled Fisherman
- Orlando Gonzalez
- Torturer
- Holly Mara Gorman
- Noble Woman
- David Hammond
- Knight
- Marili Kateri
- Mother of Sultan Malik Al Kamil
- Kaylee Kristin
- Dead Woman
- Dan Matteucci
- Crusader Soldier
- Eric Messner
- Priest
- Sean Collier Myers
- Muslim Soldier
- Eric Oasis Myrieckes
- African Warrior
- John Peddie
- Leper
- Rick Samuel
- Villager
- Kamryn Schneider
- Leper Girl
- Ashna Sharan
- Egyptian Mobber
- Janet Devine Smith
- Lady in Waiting
- Philip Stamper
- Friend #2
- Scott Swope
- Crusader Swordsman
- Matthew Alan Ward
- Crusader Soldier
- Abey Xashi
- Sultan's Guard
- Abdullah Amin
- Ottoman soldier
- Sean M. Brown
- Crusader General
- Alejandro Chamorro
- Muslim
- David Neil Cohen
- Crusader
- Dom DiMercurio
- Perugian Prison Guard
- Mark Falvo
- Roman Catholic Priest
- Kazz Felix-Hawver
- Peasant
- Dave Ferrier
- Crusader
- Brian Foreman
- Cardinal
- Marc Goodman
- Italian Citizen
- John Jarvis
- Drunk in the street
- Kearon Lehman
- Crusader Warrior Leader
- Randy Thomas Lindsay
- Crusader
- Brian McCusker
- Soldier
- Mike Miedzinski
- Muslim Crusader
- Jesse Milliner
- Tavern Patron
- Benjamin Paul Morris
- Roman Knight
- Glenn Nelson
- Emperor's Guard
- Robert Olausen
- Franciscan Friar
- Patrick Opitz
- Crusader
- Felix Quiñones
- Orlando - Palace Guard
- Harvey Roberts
- Crusader
- Dan Shortt
- Crusader
- Michael Sigler
- Roman Priest
- Fabian Starr
- Armed Guard
- Chuck Taber
- Crusader
- Paul Wallis
- Crusader Knight
- Chris Wolfe
- Crusader
- Tim R. Worley
- St. Francis Converted Follower
- Scott Zeiss
- Knight
