- Milton Sills
- Sir Oliver Tressilian
- Enid Bennett
- Lady Rosamund Godolphin
- Lloyd Hughes
- Lionel Tressilian
- Wallace Beery
- Captain Jasper Leigh
- Marc McDermott
- Sir John Killigrew
- Wallace MacDonald
- Peter Godolphin
- Bert Woodruff
- Nick
- Claire Du Brey
- Siren
- Lionel Belmore
- Justice Anthony Baine
- Christina Montt
- The Infanta of Spain
- Albert Prisco
- Yusuf-Ben-Moktar
- Frank Currier
- Asad-ed-Din - Basha of Algiers
- William Collier Jr.
- Marsak
- Medea Radzina
- Fenzileh
- Fred DeSilva
- Ali
- Kathleen Key
- Andalusian Slave Girl
- Hector V. Sarno
- Tsmanni
- Robert Bolder
- Ayoub
- Fred Spencer
- Boatswain
- S.E. Jennings
- Captain of Asad's Guards
- Henry A. Barrows
- Bishop
- Carl D. Bruner
- Undetermined Secondary Role
- Edwards Davis
- Chief Justice of England
- Andrew Johnston
- Sir Walter
- Theodore Lorch
- Turkish Merchant
- Louis Morrison
- Innkeeper
- George O'Brien
- Galley Slave
- Kate Price
- Innkeeper's Wife
- George Regas
- Oarsman
- George Romain
- Spanish Commander
- Walter Wilkinson
- Oliver's Young Son
- Nancy Zann
- Spanish Slave Girl
