- Cornel Wilde
- Maj. John Boulton
- Michael Wilding
- Maj. John Andre
- George Sanders
- Dr. Jonathan Odell
- Anne Francis
- Sally Cameron
- Robert Douglas
- Gen. Benedict Arnold
- John McIntire
- Gen. Robert Howe
- Rhys Williams
- Peter Andre
- John Dehner
- Nathanael Greene
- James Westerfield
- Col. Jameson
- Ashley Cowan
- Mr. Brown
- Paul Cavanagh
- Sir Henry Clinton
- John Alderson
- Mr. Durkin
- John O'Malley
- Col. Winfield
- Bobby Driscoll
- Ben Potter
- Peter Adams
- Lt. Blair
- Don Anderson
- Trial Spectator
- Wilson Benge
- Servant
- John Blackburn
- Captain
- George Blagoi
- Judge on Panel
- John Bose
- Soldier
- Chet Brandenburg
- Soldier
- Noble 'Kid' Chissell
- Soldier
- Tristram Coffin
- Col. Varick
- Phyllis Coghlan
- Woman
- Dee Cooper
- Soldier
- Tom Cound
- English Soldier
- Anthony Dearden
- Capt. De Lancey
- Jack Deery
- Soldier
- Leslie Denison
- Capt. Sutherland
- Jimmy Dime
- Soldier
- Robert Dix
- Lt. Evans
- Byron Foulger
- Man with Delivery for Mr. Moody
- Michael Fox
- Maj. Russell
- Paul Frees
- Narrator
- Ronald Green
- Lieutenant
- Dabbs Greer
- Capt. Brewster
- Chick Hannan
- Solder
- Don C. Harvey
- Captain Leading Squad at Execution
- Steve Hayes
- Mr. Nyby
- Jim Hayward
- Joshua Smith
- Wes Hudman
- Capt. Sheldon
- Robin Hughes
- Col. Tarleton
- Olaf Hytten
- Maj. Andre's Butler
- Charles Keane
- Sergeant
- Dennis King Jr.
- Boatswain's Mate
- Guy Kingsford
- Officer
- Anne Kunde
- Cook
- Ethan Laidlaw
- Executioner
- Bruce Lester
- Col. Simcoe
- Jon Locke
- Lieutenant
- Keith McConnell
- Lieutenant
- Owen McGiveney
- Servant
- Frank Mills
- Tony - Innkeeper
- Charles Morton
- Judge on Panel
- Tim Nelson
- British Soldier
- William H. O'Brien
- Waiter at Party
- Vesey O'Davoren
- Butler
- Manuel ParÃs
- Servant
- Richard Peel
- Sailor
- George Peters
- Staff Officer
- Jennifer Raine
- Miss Trumbull
- Barry Regan
- Lieutenant
- Vernon Rich
- Colonel
- Gordon Richards
- Mr. Cameron
- Victor Romito
- Soldier
- Phil Schumacher
- Sailor
- Scott Seaton
- Trial Spectator
- Sammy Shack
- Soldier
- Clint Sharp
- British Soldier
- Dick Simmons
- Sergeant with Signalman
- Robert Stevenson
- Stout Man
- Gilchrist Stuart
- Officer
- Rick Vallin
- Mounted Lieutenant Escorting Maj. Andre
- Harlan Warde
- Captain with Colonel Jameson
- Charles Watts
- Will Potter
- Rush Williams
- Soldier
