- Charlton Heston
- James 'Jim' Aherne Jr. / War Bonnet
- Susan Morrow
- Tally Hathersall
- Peter Hansen
- Lt. Weston Hathersall
- Joan Taylor
- Luta
- Richard Rober
- Capt. Arnold Vaugant
- Don Porter
- Running Dog
- Ted de Corsia
- Iron Breast
- Ian MacDonald
- Chief Yellow Eagle
- Milburn Stone
- Cpl. Martin
- Angela Clarke
- Pehangi
- Orley Lindgren
- 'Whooper' Aherne, Jim as a boy
- Michael Tolan
- Long Mane
- Howard Negley
- Col. Robert Ellis
- Frank Richards
- Sgt. Norris
- Kirk Alyn
- Orderly
- Chief American Horse
- Indian
- Beulah Archuletta
- Miniconjou Woman
- Iron Eyes Cody
- Warrior
- Frank Cordell
- Cavalryman
- Roger Creed
- Holmes
- Jerado Decordovier
- Indian
- Jimmie Dundee
- Dark Hawk
- Ben Black Elk Sr.
- Crow Chief
- Marion Gray
- Mrs. Ellis
- Jim Hayward
- Doctor
- King Cotton the Horse
- Luta's Horse
- John Miljan
- Chief White Thunder
- David Miller
- Lt. Eric Stanley
- John S. Peters
- Sgt. Dolin
- Charles Soldani
- Indian
- James Van Horn
- Cavalryman
- Willard W. Willingham
- Cavalryman
- Henry Wills
- Firth
