- Barry Watson
- Nick DeMarco
- Melissa Sagemiller
- Carol Guthrie
- Scott Grimes
- John Guthrie
- Melissa Joan Hart
- Rose DeMarco
- Jaleel White
- Paul Greenberg
- Tucker Meek
- Billy Guthrie
- Wendy Williams
- Pastor Ruth
- Alimi Ballard
- Steve Repperton
- John Ratzenberger
- Warden
- Matthew Porter
- Walter Banfield
- P.J. Marino
- Foreman
- Dahn Ballard
- Olivia
- Andrea Cirie
- Mrs. Stanwyck
- Lucy DeVito
- June
- Michael Patrick Lane
- Bartender
- Brian J. Carter
- Ernie
- Matthew F. O'Connor
- Phil
- Bonnie Discepolo
- Woman in Bar
- Cameron Meyer
- Chairwoman
- Jonathan Savage
- Jerky Kid
- Kairo Chelani Ballard
- Little Boy 1
- Braydon Wilkerson
- Little Boy 2
- Christopher Savage
- Little Boy 3
- Charlie Santoyo
- Little Boy 4
- Mason Lahd Wilkerson
- Little Boy 5
- Olivia Bell-Cross
- Little Girl 1
- Destiny Figueroa
- Little Girl 2
- Naya Seray Ballard
- Little Girl 3
- Mitch Longley
- Mr. Waxman
- Enrique Menendez
- Parole Board Member 2
- Brian Hart
- Police Officer
- Becky Baker
- Young Mother
- Joseph Basile
- Contractor
- David Boston
- Corrections Officer
- Elizabeth Hart
- Elf
- Mackenzie Lee Hart
- Elf
- William Hart
- Poker Player
- Hudson Meek
- Wiseman
- Mark Wilkerson
- Sentry
- Tucker Wilkerson
- Little Boy on Santa's Lap
