- Kirby Heyborne
- Jared Phelps
- Daryn Tufts
- Basketball Player
- Will Swenson
- Kori Swenson
- Britani Bateman
- Kelly Powers
- Tracy Ann Evans
- Emma Phelps
- Merrill Dodge
- Brigham Phelps
- Michael Birkeland
- Dewey
- Maren Ord
- Sariah Phelps
- Big Budah
- Humu
- Curt Doussett
- Defense Attorney
- Wally Joyner
- Brother Colin Jensen
- Jericho Road
- Prison Band
- Gary Crowton
- Bishop Andrews
- Rulon Gardner
- Good Samaritan
- Larry H. Miller
- Car Dealer
- Jimmy Chunga
- Phat Cop
- Ruth Hale
- Church Organist
- Ruth Todd
- News Woman
- Randall Carlisle
- News Man
- Scott Christopher
- District Attorney
- Lincoln Hoppe
- Steve
- Mitch English
- Lloyd Finderlyon
- Anne Kathryn Parma
- Ruth Phelps
- Mark David Christenson
- Sam Phelps
- Haven Andrus
- (Uncredited)
- Scott Champion
- Sister's Date
- Cody Cowdell
- Boy Scout
- Holly Cowdell
- Midnight Home Teachee
- Mark Cowdell
- Elders Quorum President
- Richard Dayhuff
- Elder Powers
- Lee Fobert
- Home Teacher
- Coz Green
- Waiter
- Allan Groves
- Kelly's Friend
- Matt Hale
- Dancer
- Jared Hess
- LD3 Nerd
- RuthAnn Hogue
- Mother of the Groom
- Jeremy Hoover
- Frat Guy
- Adam Johnson
- Tucker
- Kristi Labrum
- Dance Greeter
- Sherry Leigh
- Julie Jensen
- Patrick Livingston
- Telemarketer
- Chad Long
- LD3 Fat Guy
- Christopher Robin Miller
- The Jeweler
- John E. Moyer
- Would-Be Home Teacher
- Keith Ross Nelson
- Rent To Own Manager
- Erin Robert
- Molly
- The Rockamatics
- Wedding Band
- Jonathan Rudy
- Priest
- Shaun Schofield
- Clayton Boy
- Jake Suazo
- Tommy
- Robert Swenson
- Zak
- Cami Twede
- Candi
- Michelle Wright
- Attorney
- Micah Young
- Basketball Player
- B. Adam Baillio
- Extra
