- Chris Abbey Jr.
- Michael Matthews / The Angel
- Gabriel Kamas
- The Demon
- Chris Massoglia
- Wesley
- Leonard Searcy
- Allan Henderson
- Miranda Shaughnessy
- Carmen
- Alan Arias
- Reid
- Roceathia Cornell
- Michael's Mother / Pearl
- Nick Hansen
- Police Chief
- Darrin Barber
- Gang Member 1
- Ryan J. Gilmer
- Reptilian Officer
- Bryce Williams
- Michael's Friend
- Ava Justin
- Michael's Cousin
- Gabi Del Moral
- Officer Gabi
- Shakademic
- Gang Member 2
- Jordan Rholing
- Gang Member 3
- Dominique Snider
- Gang Member 4
- Michael Paul Quinn
- Reptillian 2 / Police Chief (as Michael Quinn)
- Payne Campaign
- Reptilian 3
- Eric Parker
- Reptilian 4
- Anthony Tunstall
- Reptilian 5
- Blair Smith
- Reptilian 6
- Zac Kasecky
- Reptilian 7
- Benjamin Terry
- Reptilian 8
- Abigail Sharp
- Reptilian 9
- Lizette Fonesca
- Interviewee Student
- Joel Thingvall
- Interviewee Teacher
- Mati Irre
- Victim / Interviewee
- Karen Voels
- Religious Interviewee
- Andrew Stecker
- Conspiracy Theorist
- Haleh Saberi
- News Anchor
- Ben Hughes
- News Announcer / Mugger (voice)
- Gwen Ruhoff
- Stabbing Victim
