- Nathan Lane
- Max Bialystock
- Matthew Broderick
- Leo Bloom
- Uma Thurman
- Ulla
- Will Ferrell
- Franz Liebkind
- Gary Beach
- Roger DeBris
- Roger Bart
- Carmen Ghia
- Eileen Essell
- Hold Me-Touch Me
- Michael McKean
- Prison Trustee
- David Huddleston
- Judge
- Debra Monk
- Lick Me-Bite Me
- Andrea Martin
- Kiss Me-Feel Me
- Jon Lovitz
- Mr. Marks
- Bryn Dowling
- Usherette / Girl with Pearls / Little Old Lady / Bavarian Peasant
- Meg Gillentine
- Usherette / Girl with Pearls / Little Old Lady / Tapping Brown Shirt
- Kevin Ligon
- Workman / Little Old Lady
- Ray Wills
- Bum
- Marilyn Sokol
- Bag Lady
- Brad Oscar
- Cab Driver
- Tory Ross
- Misfit Showgirl
- Brent Barrett
- Brian the Set Designer
- Peter Bartlett
- Kevin the Costume Designer
- Jim Borstelmann
- Scott the Choreographer / Donald Dinsmore / Little Old Lady / Bavarian Peasant
- Kathy Fitzgerald
- Shirley Markowitz / Little Old Lady
- Jai Rodriguez
- Sabu the Houseboy
- Mike Jackson
- Injun Jack
- Keith Kuhl
- First Mate Kyle / Prisoners of Love Dancer
- Keith Lamelle Thomas
- Patrolman Pete
- Roland Rusinek
- Jack Lapidus
- Jason Antoon
- Jason Green
- Madeline Doherty
- Mildred the Audition Accompanist / Little Old Lady (as Madeleine Doherty)
- Jonathan Freeman
- Ticket Taker
- Mike McGowan
- Workman #2 / Little Old Lady
- Timothy Gulan
- Gunter / Accountant
- Patrick S. Brady
- Conductor
- John Barrowman
- Lead Tenor
- Michael McCormick
- Mr. Shocked
- Susann Fletcher
- Mrs. Bewildered
- Michael Thomas Holmes
- Stormtrooper Rolf / Auditioner
- Ronn Carroll
- Stormtrooper Mel
- Ruth Williamson
- Snooty Woman
- John C. Vennema
- Stuffy Man
- Fred Applegate
- Officer O'Toole
- Jerry Richardson
- Officer O'Reilly
- Timothy Shew
- Officer O'Rourke
- Danny Mastrogiorgio
- Jail Guard
- Richard Kind
- Jury Foreman
- Naomi Kakuk
- Stenographer / Girl with Pearls / Little Old Lady
- Thomas Meehan
- Max's Attorney
- Brian Rogalski
- Convict #1
- Jimmy Smagula
- Convict #2
- James Biberi
- Sing Sing Prison Guard
- Mel Brooks
- Hilda the Pigeon / Tom the Cat (voice)
- Rachel Montez Minor
- First Nighter
- John Treacy Egan
- First Nighter
- Robert Fowler
- First Nighter / Little Old Lady
- Jack Hayes
- First Nighter
- Angelique Ilo
- First Nighter / Little Old Lady
- Stephanie Michels
- First Nighter
- Dana Moore
- First Nighter
- Christopher Nilsson
- First Nighter
- Christina Marie Norrup
- First Nighter / Little Old Lady (as Christina Norrup)
- Chris Michael Peterson
- First Nighter / Accountant (as Chris Peterson)
- Mia Price
- First Nighter / Girl with Pearls / Little Old Lady
- Wayne Schroder
- First Nighter
- John Sloman
- First Nighter
- Abe Sylvia
- First Nighter
- Craig Waletzko
- First Nighter / Accountant
- Wendy Waring
- First Nighter / Girl with Pearls / Little Old Lady / Showgirl / Prisoners of Love Dancer
- Jeff Williams
- First Nighter
- Karen Ziemba
- First Nighter
- Matt Allen
- Accountant
- Matt Baker
- Accountant
- Ken Barnett
- Accountant
- Alan Bennett
- Accountant
- D.B. Bonds
- Accountant / Stormtrooper
- Harry Bouvy
- Accountant
- Patrick Boyd
- Accountant
- Liam Burke
- Accountant
- Eric Michael Gillett
- Accountant
- Justin Greer
- Accountant / Little Old Lady
- Peter Gregus
- Accountant
- Eric Gunhus
- Accountant / Little Old Lady
- David Havasi
- Accountant
- Jason Lacayo
- Accountant
- Jamie Laverdier
- Accountant
- Mark Ledbetter
- Accountant
- David Lowenstein
- Accountant
- Ira Mont
- Accountant
- Joseph Mooradian
- Accountant
- Patrick Mullaney
- Accountant
- Marcus Nance
- Accountant
- Nick Santa Maria
- Accountant
- Denton Tarver
- Accountant
- Patrick Wetzel
- Accountant / Little Old Lady / Bavarian Peasant
- Steve Wilson
- Accountant
- Kent Zimmerman
- Accountant
- Leanne Bowman
- Girl with Pearls
- Angie C. Creighton
- Girl with Pearls / Little Old Lady
- Jennifer Lee Crowl
- Girl with Pearls / Little Old Lady
- Holly Cruikshank
- Girl with Pearls / Showgirl / Prisoners of Love Dancer
- Colleen Dunn
- Girl with Pearls
- Jenny Gruby Field
- Girl with Pearls
- Kimberly Jones
- Girl with Pearls / Little Old Lady / Showgirl / Prisoners of Love Dancer
- Rhonda Kaufman
- Girl with Pearls
- Charley King
- Girl with Pearls
- Renee Klapmeyer
- Girl with Pearls / Little Old Lady
- Alison Levenberg
- Girl with Pearls / Little Old Lady / Tapping Brown Shirt
- Sarah Misiano
- Girl with Pearls / Little Old Lady
- Kandice Pelletier
- Girl with Pearls
- Katherine Marie Schwing
- Girl with Pearls
- Michele Utzig
- Girl with Pearls
- Melanie Allen
- Little Old Lady
- Jane Altman
- Little Old Lady
- Piper Lindsay Arpan
- Little Old Lady / Prisoners of Love Dancer
- Mary Ellen Ashley
- Little Old Lady
- Margery Beddow
- Little Old Lady
- Mimi Bensinger
- Little Old Lady
- Pam Bradley
- Little Old Lady
- Maureen Brennan
- Little Old Lady
- Jane Brockman
- Little Old Lady
- Barbara Broughton
- Little Old Lady
- Kimberly Calore
- Little Old Lady / Tapping Brown Shirt
- Alice Cannon
- Little Old Lady
- Warren Carlyle
- Little Old Lady
- Eileen Casey
- Little Old Lady
- Erin Crouch
- Little Old Lady / Bavarian Peasant
- Diane J. Findlay
- Little Old Lady
- Norma Fire
- Little Old Lady
- Sondra Gorney
- Little Old Lady
- James Gray
- Little Old Lady
- Ashley Amber Haas
- Little Old Lady
- James Hadley
- Little Old Lady
- Mary Ann Hannon
- Little Old Lady
- Marcia Haufrecht
- Little Old Lady
- Cynthia Leigh Heim
- Little Old Lady
- Kimberly Hester
- Little Old Lady
- Chris Holly
- Little Old Lady
- Stacey Todd Holt
- Little Old Lady
- Shauna Hoskin
- Little Old Lady
- Joan Jaffe
- Little Old Lady
- Nancy Johnston
- Little Old Lady
- Shari Jordan
- Little Old Lady / Bavarian Peasant
- Mary Looram
- Little Old Lady
- Dana Lorge
- Little Old Lady
- C.C. Loveheart
- Little Old Lady
- Melissa Rae Mahon
- Little Old Lady
- Patricia Mariano
- Little Old Lady
- Peter Marinos
- Little Old Lady
- Lucy Martin
- Little Old Lady
- Liz McKendry
- Little Old Lady
- Jeannine Moore
- Little Old Lady
- Francine Myles
- Little Old Lady
- Jan Neuberger
- Little Old Lady
- Denise Nolin
- Little Old Lady
- Sylvia Norman
- Little Old Lady
- Nancy Ozelli
- Little Old Lady
- Jessica Pariseau
- Little Old Lady
- Darcy Pulliam
- Little Old Lady
- Rita Rehn
- Little Old Lady
- Erika Rominger
- Little Old Lady
- Lisa St. Lou
- Little Old Lady
- Jason Patrick Sands
- Little Old Lady
- Joy Seligsohn
- Little Old Lady
- Letty Serra
- Little Old Lady
- Karen Shallo
- Little Old Lady
- Jessica Sheridan
- Little Old Lady / Bavarian Peasant
- Jennifer Smith
- Little Old Lady
- Tracy Terstriep
- Little Old Lady
- Cynthia Thole
- Little Old Lady
- Chryssie Whitehead
- Little Old Lady
- Jill Wolins
- Little Old Lady
- Courtney Young
- Little Old Lady / Prisoners of Love Dancer
- Will Armstrong
- Auditioner
- Collin Baja
- Auditioner
- Seth Belliston
- Auditioner
- Scott Davidson
- Auditioner / Bavarian Peasant
- Gary Franco
- Auditioner
- Sean Martin Hingston
- Auditioner / Tapping Brown Shirt / Prisoners of Love Dancer
- Michael Jablonski
- Auditioner
- Terace Jones
- Auditioner
- James Kinney
- Auditioner
- Richie Mastascusa
- Auditioner
- Barry McNabb
- Auditioner
- Mark Myars
- Auditioner
- Wes Pope
- Auditioner
- Danny Rutigliano
- Auditioner
- John Salvatore
- Auditioner
- Marcos Santana
- Auditioner
- Chad Schiro
- Auditioner
- Courter Simmons
- Auditioner
- Robert Wersinger
- Auditioner
- Michael Goddard
- Bavarian Peasant
- Kelly Sullivan
- Bavarian Peasant
- Matthew J. Vargo
- Bavarian Peasant
- Angie Schworer
- Showgirl
- Jeremy Benton
- Tapping Brown Shirt
- Scott Fowler
- Tapping Brown Shirt
- Brad Musgrove
- Tapping Brown Shirt
- Eric Altheide
- Stormtrooper
- Robert Bartley
- Stormtrooper
- Joshua Bennett
- Stormtrooper
- Timothy Bish
- Stormtrooper
- Dan Bittner
- Stormtrooper
- Scott Blokker
- Stormtrooper
- Shane Braddock
- Stormtrooper
- Barry Brown
- Stormtrooper
- Mark Burrell
- Stormtrooper
- Jordan Cable
- Stormtrooper
- Matthew Cassaro
- Stormtrooper
- Todd Alan Crain
- Stormtrooper
- Michael Todd Curry
- Stormtrooper
- Wyatt Darling
- Stormtrooper
- Kip Driver
- Stormtrooper
- Charles Duff
- Stormtrooper
- Andrew Fitch
- Stormtrooper
- Ben Franklin
- Stormtrooper
- Derek M. Gatts
- Stormtrooper
- Michael Gillis
- Stormtrooper
- Aaron Hamilton
- Stormtrooper
- Brad Hampton
- Stormtrooper
- Jamie R. Harris
- Stormtrooper
- Bram Heidinger
- Stormtrooper
- Andy Kelso
- Stormtrooper
- Paul Lane
- Stormtrooper
- Brian J. Marcum
- Stormtrooper
- Matthew Morris
- Stormtrooper
- Patrick Holden O'Neill
- Stormtrooper
- Steve Parmenter
- Stormtrooper
- Adam Pelty
- Stormtrooper
- Jason Craig Poole
- Stormtrooper
- Josh Rhodes
- Stormtrooper
- Ed Roggenkamp
- Stormtrooper
- J. Brandon Savage
- Stormtrooper
- Jonathan Sexsmith
- Stormtrooper
- Jerry Sher
- Stormtrooper
- David Spangenthal
- Stormtrooper
- Jake Speck
- Stormtrooper
- Billy Sprague Jr.
- Stormtrooper
- Jonathan Stahl
- Stormtrooper
- Stephen Fletcher
- Stormtrooper
- Cameron Stevens
- Stormtrooper
- Jeremy J. Sullivan
- Stormtrooper
- Charlie Sutton
- Stormtrooper
- Sean van der Wilt
- Stormtrooper
- Tommy Walker
- Stormtrooper
- Matt Wall
- Stormtrooper
- John Wannen Jr.
- Stormtrooper
- Theis Weckesser
- Stormtrooper
- Nathan Williams
- Stormtrooper
- Sheridan Wright
- Stormtrooper
- Julio Agustin
- Samba Band
- Sebastian La Cause
- Samba Band
- J.C. Montgomery
- Samba Band
- Chris Vasquez
- Samba Band
- David Brown
- Convict
- Gregory Butler
- Convict
- Jerry Ciauri
- Convict
- Teddy Coluca
- Convict
- Alexander Gemignani
- Convict
- Sean Johnson
- Convict
- Dominique Kelley
- Convict
- Bobby Pestka
- Convict
- Al D. Rodriguez
- Convict
- Terry Schappert
- Convict
- Jim Tooey
- Convict
- Michael Tourek
- Convict
- Adam Zotovich
- Convict
- Robert Armitage
- Prisoners of Love Dancer
- James Brown III
- Prisoners of Love Dancer
- Amy Hall
- Prisoners of Love Dancer
- Luke Longacre
- Prisoners of Love Dancer
- Barrett Martin
- Prisoners of Love Dancer
- Karl Warden
- Prisoners of Love Dancer
- Mindy Wild
- Prisoners of Love Dancer
- Flint Beverage
- Astor Bartender
- Robert Bizik
- Audience Member
- Randy Blair
- Reporter
- Annie Cavalero
- Audience Member
- Jennifer Clippinger
- Ensemble
- Bob DeVito
- Prisoner
- George Dvorsky
- Ensemble
- Hunter Foster
- Ensemble
- Tony Galtieri
- Opera Patron
- Steve Geary
- Cop
- Francesca Harper
- Ensemble
- Ellen Harvey
- Mrs. Battle-Axe
- Daniel Herron
- Ensemble
- Rick Kain
- Cab Passenger
- Judy Kaye
- Ensemble
- Daniel Koenig
- Audience Member
- Eric Lombart
- Audience Member
- Richard Lounello
- Prisoner of Love
- Pete Macnamara
- Prison Guard
- Dominick Mancino
- First Nighter
- Michael X. Martin
- Ensemble
- Darrell Matlock
- Theater Patron
- Riley G. Matthews Jr.
- Bailiff
- Sally Mayes
- Ensemble
- Susan McBrien
- Courtroom Observer
- David McDaniel
- Shubert Alley Man
- Dolores McDougal
- Courtroom Observer
- Cody Melton
- Wannabe Hitler
- Robert Montano
- Ensemble
- Josh Mowery
- Outraged Theatre Patron
- Bill Nolte
- Ensemble
- Nancy Opel
- Ensemble
- Nancy Otero
- Audience Member
- Marilyn Pasekoff
- Ensemble
- Raymond Rodriguez
- Ensemble
- Joe Rosario
- Sewer
- Luke Rosen
- Sign Builder
- Paul Scannapieco
- Convict #13 Louie
- Jason B. Schmidt
- Audience Member
- Kevin Sebastian
- Audience Member
- Matt Semino
- Audience Member
- Kent Sladyk
- Broadway Patron
- Nell Snaidas
- Ensemble
- Stella Stark
- Dancer
- Frank Stellato
- Outraged Theatre Patron
- Jenny Lynn Suckling
- Ensemble
- Sonny Vellozzi
- Audience Member
- Jay Brian Winnick
- Pretzel Vendor
- Cara Winter
- Audience Member
- Cornell Womack
- Prison Extra
- Victor Yerrid
- Adolph Pigeon
- Dianne Zaremba
- Showgirl
- Steven Zweigbaum
- Stage Manager
