- Jeremy Oliveria
- Christian
- Matthew McAuliffe
- Narrator
- Reavah Hope
- Church Goer
- Kylon Brune
- Church Goer
- Wright Kieran
- Church Goer
- Katrina Sewell
- Church Goer
- Julius Catheart
- Church Goer
- Scarlett West
- Church Goer
- Hannah Brasseur
- Church Goer
- Tonya Ruiz
- Church Goer
- Josiah Oliveria
- Church Goer
- Patricia Monlard
- Church Goer
- Daniel MacDowell
- Young Narrator
- Mera Oliveria
- Christian's Wife
- Jordan Gotzman
- Christian's Daughter
- Hudson Gotzman
- Christian's Older Son
- Landon Gotzman
- Christians Younger Son
- Sean Snyder
- Evangelis
- Josh Oliveria
- Mr. Turnback
- Tina Williams
- Mrs. Stubborn
- Kelly Harrington
- Help
- Brandon Fair
- Worldly Wiseman
- Dave Reichard
- Goodwill
- Larry Anderson
- Interpreter
- Curt Hadley
- Dust Sweeper
- Heather Oliveria
- Lovely Lady
- Isaiah Peters
- Muck Raker
- Robin Cyphers
- Angel with Crown
- Richard Bokish
- Man with Nightmare
- Mike Hartwell
- Atheist
- John Henderson
- Angel One
- Ben Heideggar
- Angel Two
- Mitch Glockling
- Apollyon
- Rousseaux Brasseur
- Faithful
- Whitney Brown
- Worldliness
- Scott Furrey
- Jester
- B. Ryan Gaston
- Drunken Gepetto
- Jacon Terando
- Beelzebub
- Shana Brown
- Live-Loose (Amy Adams)
- Stacey Moberly
- Hate-light
- Roman Watson
- Angel Three
- Michael Combs
- Angel Four (Derek)
