- Joe DeRita
- Curly-Joe
- Larry Fine
- Larry
- Moe Howard
- Moe
- Adam West
- Kenneth Cabot
- Nancy Kovack
- Annie Oakley
- Mort Mills
- Trigger Mortis
- Don Lamond
- Rance Roden
- Rex Holman
- Sunstroke Kid
- Emil Sitka
- Mr. Abernathy / Witch Doctor / Cavalry Colonel
- Henry Gibson
- Charlie Horse
- Murray Alper
- Chief Crazy Horse
- Tiny Brauer
- Bartender
- Sidney Marion
- Hammond
- Jeffrey Scott
- Kid
- Marilyn Fox
- Girl #1
- Audrey Betz
- Fat Squaw
- Lloyd Kino
- Japanese Moe
- Joe Bolton
- Rob Dalton
- Bill Camfield
- Wyatt Earp
- Hal Fryar
- Johnny Ringo
- Johnny Ginger
- Billy the Kid
- Wayne Mack
- Jesse James
- Ed T. McDonnell
- Bat Masterson
- Bruce Sedley
- Cole Younger
- Paul Shannon
- Wild Bill Hickok
- Sally Starr
- Belle Starr
- George American Horse
- Indian
- Paul Bradley
- Townsman
- James J. Casino
- Townsman
- George DeNormand
- Townsman
- Jimmy Dime
- Townsman
- Bill Dyer
- Townsman
- Joe Evans
- Undertaker
- Duke Fishman
- Townsman
- Paul Frees
- Narrator / The Magic Talking Mirror (voice) (uncredited)
- Jack Gordon
- Townsman
- Raven Grey Eagle
- Indian
- Herman Hack
- Townsman
- Chester Hayes
- Indian
- Foster Hood
- Indian
- Gustave Lax
- Barfly
- Fred Rapport
- Townsman
- Lucian Tiger
- Indian
- Wally West
- Townsman
