- Jack Buetel
- Billy the Kid
- Jane Russell
- Rio McDonald
- Thomas Mitchell
- Pat Garrett
- Walter Huston
- Doc Holliday
- Mimi Aguglia
- Guadalupe
- Joe Sawyer
- Charley Woodruff
- Gene Rizzi
- Stranger who draws on The Kid
- Bobby Callahan
- Boy
- Martin Garralaga
- Mike - Waiter
- Ben Johnson
- Deputy
- Dickie Jones
- Boy
- Cecil Kellogg
- Deputy
- Ethan Laidlaw
- Deputy
- Ted Mapes
- Deputy
- William Newell
- Drunken Cowboy
- Emory Parnell
- Dolan - Man Entering Saloon
- Edward Peil Sr.
- Swanson - Deputy
- Wallace Reid Jr.
- Townsman Bystander
- Julian Rivero
- Pablo
- Lee Shumway
- Card Dealer
- William Steele
- Deputy
- Harry Strang
- Townsman at Sheriff's Office
- Frank Ward
- Boy
- Pat West
- Bartender
