- James Cagney
- Jim Kincaid
- Humphrey Bogart
- Whip McCord
- Rosemary Lane
- Jane Hardwick
- Donald Crisp
- Judge Hardwick
- Harvey Stephens
- Ned Kincaid
- Hugh Sothern
- John Kincaid
- Charles Middleton
- Alec Martin
- Edward Pawley
- Doolin
- Ward Bond
- Wes Handley
- Lew Harvey
- Curley
- Trevor Bardette
- Indian Jack Pasco
- John Miljan
- Ringo
- Arthur Aylesworth
- Judge Morgan
- Irving Bacon
- Hotel Clerk
- Joe Devlin
- Keely - Bartender
- Wade Boteler
- Sheriff
- Gene Alsace
- McCord Henchman
- Earl Askam
- Joe - Train Mail Clerk
- Don Barclay
- Drunk
- Clem Bevans
- Postman
- Danny Borzage
- Accordionist
- Ed Brady
- Jury Foreman
- Al Bridge
- Would-Be Settler
- Nora Bush
- Settler
- Bob Card
- Room 6 Occupant
- Glen Cavender
- Would-Be Settler
- Jess Cavin
- Townsman
- Tom Chatterton
- Homesteader
- George Chesebro
- Deputy
- Martin Cichy
- Townsman
- Bill Cody
- Henchman Outside Saloon
- Tex Cooper
- Townsman
- Jack Curtis
- Townsman
- Tex Driscoll
- Settler
- Earl Dwire
- Relay Station Man
- Joe Farey
- Townsman
- Rosina Galli
- Manuelita
- Sam Garrett
- Rider / Roper (uncredited)
- Jack Gordon
- Townsman
- Kit Guard
- Juror #8
- Herman Hack
- Townsman
- John Harron
- President Cleveland's Secretary
- Herbert Heywood
- Deputy
- Stuart Holmes
- President Grover Cleveland
- Robert Homans
- Bartender
- Al J. Jennings
- Townsman
- Soledad Jiménez
- Jane's Servant
- Jack Kenny
- Townsman
- Bob Kortman
- Juror #9
- Al Kunde
- Townsman
- Anne Kunde
- Settler
- Richard LaMarr
- Townsman
- George Lloyd
- Bartender in Missouri
- Jim Mason
- Man in Hotel
- Ray Mayer
- Piano Player
- Frank Mayo
- Land Agent
- Robert Milasch
- Townsman
- Mike Morelli
- Townsman
- Jack Mower
- Mail Clerk on Train
- Horace Murphy
- Bartender
- Harry Myers
- Banker
- Tex Phelps
- Would-Be Settler
- George Regas
- Pedro
- John Rice
- Townsman
- John J. Richardson
- Would-Be Settler
- Joe Rickson
- Homesteader
- Cliff Saum
- Would-Be Settler
- Jeffrey Sayre
- 'Times' Reporter
- Allen D. Sewall
- Townsman
- Lucile Sewall
- Settler
- Sammy Shack
- Townsman
- Elliott Sullivan
- McCord's Henchman
- William Sundholm
- Townsman
- Harry Tenbrook
- Juror #4
- Jack Tornek
- Would-Be Settler
- Sailor Vincent
- Townsman
- Blackie Whiteford
- Juror
- Dan Wolheim
- Deputy
